Reviews

Cranford with Tamsin Greig at Orange Tree Theatre – review

Lin Coghlan and Shaun McKenna’s new stage adaptation of the Elizabeth Gaskell novel runs until 16 January

Aliya Al-Hassan

Aliya Al-Hassan

| Richmond |

16 November 2026

Tamsin Greig with Sara Powell and Sara Crowe in Cranford
Tamsin Greig with Sara Powell and Sara Crowe in Cranford, © Marc Brenner

The belief that there is no gentile way to eat an orange is an appropriate summary of the collective social attitudes in Lin Coghlan and Shaun McKenna’s new adaptation of Elizabeth Gaskell’s Cranford. The pair reunite with director Josh Roche following their excellent RSC adaptation of The Forsyte Saga, to bring a delightfully comedic production with unexpected depths to the Orange Tree Theatre.

Based on Gaskell’s 1853 novel, we are introduced to a small Northern market town, run predominantly by women whose lives are dictated by what is deemed socially appropriate. What is proper and what is not dominates their lives. As past losses, the outside world, and external circumstances encroach on their space, they must find new ways to live and support one another.

Tamsin Greig is another big name to appear at the venue and is wonderful as protagonist Matty – a seemingly mousy and vulnerable woman who has spent her whole life sacrificing herself from any kind of involvement in it. As a spinster who found love but couldn’t pursue it, her brief reference to a recurring dream about her imaginary daughter is deeply touching. Yet her subservient attitude develops into something more resilient and stronger as she is forced to take control of her own life due to unexpected external circumstances. It’s a wonderfully subtle performance.

Greig may be the heart of the production, but this is very much an ensemble piece. Abigail Cruttenden is prim and reproving as uptight sister Deborah, later showing softness and generosity as Lady Glenmire. Sara Crowe, Alexandra Gilbreath, and Sara Powell make a comedic art of gentle gossip and mock outrage at the smallest of transgressions against civility.

Manchester-based visitor Eliza is given dignity and wry commentary by Phoebe Pryce, who plays a woman harbouring her own painful past. Acting as an unobtrusive narrator, she guides us through the story with grace and ease. Saffron Dey is also a lively presence as sparky maid, Martha. Jonny Glynn and Robert Merriam ably make up the male characters, who flit in and out of the narrative, many of whom end up determining the fates of the women.

The cast of Cranford
The cast of Cranford, © Marc Brenner

It’s a tall order to create a coherent play out of an episodic novel. Various characters and the looming spectre of industrialisation have all but been cut from the production, with Coghlan and McKenna creating a convincing narrative arc that feels consistent. Roche’s direction ramps up the comedy, with even the women’s bobbing curtsies milked for laughs. More poignant moments are given space to breathe, although the ricocheting between witticisms and pathos is occasionally too sharp.

It’s a large cast for the space and so Natalie Johnson’s design keeps things suitably sparse and simple, with uneven floorboards underfoot and three-legged stools whipped on and off stage. There are bonnets aplenty and even a lovely, bright red outfit for a cow who has lost her hair after falling into a lime pit!

Although not strictly a festive show, we begin and end at Christmas time, with holly sprigs in a small vase and the “Coventry Carol” echoing delicately in the background. If you are allergic to pantomimes, this warm, witty, and occasionally deeply affecting production will make you laugh and touch your heart.

Star
Star
Star
Star
Star
Add as a preferred
source on Google

Related Articles

See all

Theatre news & discounts

Get the best deals and latest updates on theatre and shows by signing up for WhatsOnStage newsletter today!