Jodie Prenger and Neil Hurst’s new musical parody runs until 3 January

If an award were ever handed out for the production that would most have benefited from the old adage that less is more, A Homo Alone 2 would surely be a frontrunner.
This is the third festive outing at the Other Palace Studio from Jodie Prenger and Neil Hurst, following Homo Alone in 2024 and last year’s Lovers Actually. This time, they’ve set their sights on Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, and the result is a very adult parody that loosely follows the film’s plot. Woven through it is a plethora of familiar songs, their lyrics rewritten to sit squarely in the vein of adult pantomime.
For anyone who has managed to avoid the film, Kevin McCallister boards the wrong plane, and while his family head off to Florida, he ends up alone in New York. In this version, Kevin (Thomas John Stocks) wastes little time in deciding that the best use of his unsupervised stay in the Big Apple is to bed just about every man who crosses his path.
That is where the problems start. The show is stuffed to bursting with innuendo, along with a great deal of other material that doesn’t always land. Gay sex, kink, bodily fluids and body parts are all fair game, and the tone throughout is schoolyard, often verging on the frat house.
Being unkind, one might call it puerile. It isn’t that the show lacks humour. The trouble is that so much of it rests on the notion that simply saying crude words is funny in its own right. It isn’t. It’s rather simplistic, and there is so much of it that, when the genuinely good jokes arrive (and there are a decent number of them), they feel a little wasted.
The casting doesn’t help. Stocks is probably in his mid to late twenties, but he is playing a character who, in the film, wasn’t even into his teens, and he looks the part. Watching him describe his way through a catalogue of raunchy encounters makes for an awkward evening, and it’s a discomfort the show never quite shakes off.

Thankfully, the show has two secret weapons in Charlotte Dixon and Jermaine Woods. Dixon is a delight as Donna J Trump, owner of the Plaza Hotel. Woods, amongst many roles, takes on the hotel manager played on screen by Tim Curry. Here he is rechristened Mr Timcurry and played as Frank ‘N’ Furter, Curry’s most famous role, from The Rocky Horror Show. The pair really come into their own, though, as the two criminals hell-bent on revenge against Kevin. They camp it up to the rafters, and their on-stage chemistry is a joy to watch. Whenever they share the stage, the show lifts, and their scenes together are comfortably the high point of the evening.
There are other lovely touches too. Jenny Bede plays Kevin’s mother, Catherine O’Hara’s role in the film, amongst a host of other characters. She portrays her as a full-blown impersonation of Moira Rose, the role O’Hara is now probably best known for, from Schitt’s Creek. To their credit, the writers also know full well that the original film was hardly a masterpiece. More than once, they turn its absurdities into comic set pieces, pointing out what should have happened and what quite plainly didn’t. When the gags land like this, they’re genuinely laugh-out-loud funny.
The cast give it their all, and the material is perfect fodder for hamming it up shamelessly. But, much like Lovers Actually, strong performances and a high joke rate are let down by a lack of restraint. Everything is dialled up to eleven from the off, and there it stays.
What the show needs is colour and variety, some light and shade: start at a two, nudge up to a five, leap to a nine, ease back to a six. That would have given the big laughs room to breathe. Instead, all too often it sounds like a gang of 14-year-olds fantasising about sex in a way that bears no resemblance to reality.
There is a genuinely funny show buried somewhere inside A Homo Alone 2, and in Dixon and Woods it has two performers more than capable of carrying it. Those happy to wade through a relentless stream of smut will find enough to laugh at. The rest may leave wishing someone had been brave enough to cut half the crass words and trust the good jokes to do the work.