Review Round-Up: Critics calculate success for NT’s Curious Incident

The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time runs at the NT Cottesloe until 27 October.

Michael Coveney
Whatsonstage.com
★★★★

……Simon Stephens’ perky and imaginative version of Mark Haddon’s cult 2003 novel The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, cleverly directed by Marianne Elliott, is an instant classic…On the way, there’s a lot of stuff about mathematics, but most of that is translated into a brilliant light show, and Luke Treadaway’s impersonation of Christopher Boone, the boy who knows all the countries and their capital cities, and all prime numbers up to 7507, is a really touching, probably award-winning, performance… his adventure on the train journey culminates in that terrifying sequence on the underground, which is here rendered with stage-level lights, a trapdoor and a yawning sense of danger. And his teacher suggests he deconstruct his A-level exam answer in a speech to the audience after the curtain-calls; he does, and it’s dazzling.

Andrzej Lukowski
Time Out

★★★★

…Luke Treadaway is astonishing as Christopher: with his ramrod straight posture, nervously twitching hands and high, precise voice he is strange, funny, brave and sympathetic. But he is also pitiless… It is devastating to realise, as the play goes on, that in any conventional sense of the word he will never ‘love’ his mum and dad… As his parents Ed and Judy, Paul Ritter and Nicola Walker are exceptionally powerful and poignant…This adaptation is a bit more middlebrow than I expected from the usually leftfield Stephens, but that’s fine: it’s absolutely right of him and Elliot to cook up a broadly appealing adaptation that will chime with the bulk of the book’s legions of fans.

Henry Hitchings
Evening Standard
★★★★

…Simon Stephens seems the perfect choice to adapt it for the stage… Stephens exults in imagining misfits — in all their sincerity and weirdness. The action starts with Christopher finding a dead dog.. Fidgety, annoying and occasionally profound, he is played with a mixture of grace and feverish intensity by Luke Treadaway… It’s a performance of great physical poise and stunning conviction… There’s also a little dig at the recent vogue for so-called premium seats, as some members of the audience are greeted by a sign that declares “You are sitting in a prime seat”. It’s a nod to Christopher’s mathematical enthusiasms; numbers are his friends. But all the seats here are prime: humane and stylish, The Curious Incident is a success from any angle.

Michael Billington
Guardian
★★★★

…even though I found myself resisting occasional touches of self-conscious cuteness and sentimentality in Marianne Elliott’s production, I readily acknowledge the whole thing is done with enormous flair. Playwright Simon Stephens, for a start, solves the problem confronting any adapter. First he has a teacher (Niamh Cusack) reading aloud the story … then, against Christopher’s wishes, the novel is turned into a play. This not only frames the action, but also sets up a rich tension between fiction’s invention and the obsession with facts, forensics and systemised data that is a symptom of Christopher’s autism… this is a highly skilful adaptation, and Paul Ritter and Nicola Walker as Christopher’s parents movingly remind us of the messily contradictory human emotions that co-exist with their son’s world of perfect patterns.

Patrick Marmion
Daily Mail
★★★★