Psychologically
speaking (and singing), there’s a great deal about Paul Higgins new
production of Mozart‘s Così
fan tutte to think about. Commedia dell’arte
traditions are hinted at in the semi-whiteface of Ferrando and
Guglielmo before they assume their Albanian disguises and in
Despina’s masked and beaked doctor. Guglielmo himself is the odd man
out, well before his variation in the “E nel tuo” second-act
quartet. Alfonso may be a philosopher, but there’s a tinge of sadism
as he manipulates the fidelity tests.
At
the performance I saw, Lorna Bridge took over the role of
Fiodiligi. “Come scoglio” with its chest-note to high-note
range proved taxing, though the second act “Per pietà”
deserved its applause. Dorabella fares less well in the aria stakes,
but Kitty Whately makes the most of her moments and suggests that
this sister is less to be bossed around by her older sibling than
usual. Paula Sides is the buffa soubrette to perfection with real
bite for “In uomini’ and she’s especially effective in “Una donna a
quindici anni”.
In
this production it’s not just a matter of vocal registers which
distinguishes Ferrando from Guglielmo. Anthony Gregory masters both
the lyricism of “un’ aura amorosa” and the pain of “tradito,
schernito” as Ferrando and Toby Girling provides a
mirror-image with distortion as Guglielmo. Richard Mosley-Evans is
a dominating Don Alfonso, with better articulation of Martin
Fitzpatrick‘s serviceable if not sparkling translation than some of
the other cast members can manage.