Tim Newns' production of David Storey's 1974 play at the Finborough Theatre "falls short of its full emotional impact"
For Sir Richard Kitchen life was once full of certainties. His career took him to the heart of things. He was, quite possibly, a cabinet minister, but nothing is clear any longer, except random memories of his childhood. His wife, whom he often feels is still alive, kept everything in perspective for him, and he was accustomed to being respected, and in control.
He is now watched over by a hired former soldier (Max Gold), a bullying son-in-law (Andrew MacDonald) and a daughter (Abigail Bond) who can barely keep her exasperation at bay. He can no longer make sense of what he is, or was, and engages in mental duels with those around him.
But he can't keep it up for long, and relapses into rueful silences. It is a poignant study of psychological decline, and the ways in which one's nearest and dearest come to express their affection through hostility rather than kindness.
There is a more than a hint of comparison with Pinter's No Man's Land, also written in 1974, in which an older, establishment figure is protected/imprisoned by two mysterious servants. There is a similar sense of unease underlying everything, and of deep symbolism in the sparse physical surroundings, though in the case of Sir Richard Kitchen, it is a bleak garden patio rather than a gloomy mansion.
Kitchen passes the time by making little speeches to himself. "Speeches are my fate. I shall come to your factory and make a speech", he declares to his son-in-law. He still has a wry sense of humour, though he is not certain of its purpose. He observes everyone else strutting about, going from A to B, as if going from A to B is exactly what they planned to do. He is bemused by their confidence and their sense of dogged intent.
This is therefore one hell of a part, and requires a subtly nuanced, wistful, mischievous, quicksilver performance if the play is to get up off its knees and engage us as it should. Simon Molloy makes a brave stab at it, but doesn't have the full armoury at his disposal. He is watchful and bantering by turns, but doesn't get to the heart of a once eminent man foiled, finally, by his own failing memory and the loss of a wife he mistreated and drove into the arms of another.
This is an elegiac play, and a quietly touching portrayal of the bafflement of old age. It is directed by Tim Newns in celebration of Storey's 80th birthday (on 13 July) and it is a worthy tribute. But on this showing it falls short of its full emotional impact.