Synopsis Written in 1980, Alan Bennett set this dark comedy in his home town of Leeds where an ageing couple are living in the city’s last back-to-back. With the demolition of the area in progress, Wilf and Connie are soon to be re-housed in a brand new maisonette with a waste disposal unit and non-slip vinyl flooring! When a sociologist comes to observe them in their daily life, normality takes a decidedly atypical turn...
Critics braved the wintry elements on Monday (2 February, previews from 27 January) to catch the opening night of Enjoy at the Gielgud theatre, Alan Bennett's working class comedy which was a famous “flop” when it premiered in 1980.
Christopher Luscombe's current revival has flown in the face of Enjoy's previous failure, opening to widespread critical acclaim at the Theatre Royal Bath last year, and having enjoyed a hugely successful national tour prior to its West End transfer (See News, 22 Sep 2008).
The play is set in the playwright’s home town of Leeds, where an ageing couple living in the city’s last, and soon-to-be-demolished back-to-back are soon to be re-housed in a modern maisonette. When a sociologist comes to observe them in their daily life, normality takes a decidedly atypical turn. Alison Steadman and David Troughton lead a cast that also includes Carol Macready, Josie Walker and Richard Glaves.
The reaction of the overnight critics was in stark contrast to that of their forebears nearly 30 years ago. “Devastating”, “extraordinary” and “wonderfully funny” were among the superlatives chosen to welcome Luscombe's revival. It wasn't all good news, with some labelling the play “too long” and “forced”. But the “highly charged” performances of principals Steadman and Troughton helped compensate for any grumblings about what the Daily Telegraph's Charles Spencer deemed a “modern classic”.
Michael Coveney on Whatsonstage.com (four stars) - “Alan Bennett’s 1980 play … just gets darker and bleaker. Funny isn’t really the word any more, and Luscombe’s suggestion that we take the title as an invitation (in a speech from the stage before curtain-up) seems, in retrospect, somewhat to smack of sarcasm … The highly charged performances of Alison Steadman and David Troughton as Connie and Wilfred Craven … take us to the limits of farce until the play freezes into a Beckettian landscape of senility and isolation … Luscombe’s production makes a strong case for Enjoy being Bennett’s most radical play, characteristically witty while pushing theatrical boundaries. Steadman quivers brilliantly with mock sensitivity and the songs of Ivor Novello, while Troughton threatens to explode with physical rage until subsiding into tragic insensibility. And Richard Glaves as their lost son closes each act with two of the most moving speeches on the modern stage.”
Lyn Gardner in the Guardian (three stars) - “Beneath his cuddly Winnie the Pooh persona, Alan Bennett is a vicious social satirist. Here, drawing on his own Leeds working class background, he turns his beady eye on heritage culture, as an elderly couple, Connie and Wilfred Craven, wait in their Leeds back-to-back for the bulldozers to demolish their old lives and the town planners to lead them to their new flat … Bennett's play was not a success when it premiered in 1980. Even its own author christened it 'Endure' rather than Enjoy. Perhaps it was ahead of its time. It is still too long, even in this snipped version, and there are other difficulties of tone that Christopher Luscombe's production fails to address … The final ten minutes are devastating and memorable; the rest is comic but curiously untroubling.”
Nicholas de Jongh in the Evening Standard (four stars) - “Alan Bennett has always kept a foot in the past and left more than a bit of his heart and soul there too. So it is no surprise that this extraordinary, expressionistic comedy in which Bennett looks back in regret and amusement to the decline of working class Leeds in the Seventies and to the lives of a married couple, not unlike his parents, should prove such an unusual pleasure today. Its West End premiere in 1980 was rated a failure. Christopher Luscombe’s imaginative production … revels in Enjoy’s inventive strangeness, reveals it as a nostalgic comedy whose time has come. Bennett’s surreal, satirical conceit, … imaginatively anticipates the theme park and heritage Britain of today … A high and serious comedy.”
Charles Spencer in the Daily Telegraph (four stars) - “When Alan Bennett's Enjoy first opened in 1980 it received rotten reviews and closed within weeks … Almost 30 years on, however, the piece now seems like an astonishingly prescient, blackly comic modern classic … Bennett is so routinely regarded as a national treasure that it is easy to forget how sharp and spiky his work can be, worlds removed from his cosy image. In this play, which was viewed as a piece of dodgy theatrical Absurdism by critics when it opened, he anticipates such developments as the burgeoning heritage industry, official snooping into private lives, and even reality television shows. And though it is often wonderfully funny, Enjoy is also strange, sad and disturbing … It's great to see justice finally being done to one of the richest and most original of all Alan Bennett's plays.”
Dominic Maxwell in The Times (three stars) - “The cast attack the material with relish. But the bleak view of humanity, in which frustration, despair and delusion underlie every aspect of family life, sits heavily alongside Bennett's stylistic audacity … The play's absurdism — the identically dressed observers, the blithe treatment of death and prostitution and paralysis — makes this a play of ideas, not emotions. With so many changes of gear, it's not clear what the rules are, and when anything is possible, nothing matters very much, and the characters' callousness starts to cloy … There's real pain in here, alongside some good gags and a vivid snapshot of harsh industrial life slipping into the speciousness of the service economy. But, by Bennett's standards, it all feels too forced. I can't deny the passion and the inventiveness of it, but I didn't really enjoy.”
Alan Bennett’s 1980 play, first seen in this fine production by Christopher Luscombe at the Theatre Royal Bath last August, just gets darker and bleaker. Funny isn’t really the word any more, and Luscombe’s suggestion that we take the title as an invitation (in a speech from the stage before curtain-up) seems, in retrospect, somewhat to smack of sarcasm.
With - on press night - most London musicals shut down by the snow and the West End resembling a ghost town, you felt punished enough already by just turning up. And then the highly charged performances of Alison Steadman and David Troughton as Connie and Wilfred Craven (habitually known to each other as “Mam” and “Dad”) take us to the limits of farce until the play freezes into a Beckettian landscape of senility and isolation.
The Cravens are being fingered by the authorities as typical working-class Yorkshire folk whose house will become a museum as the old area in Leeds is demolished. Dad is the victim of a hit-and-run driver who disowns his son who’s been rendered effeminate by education and yearns for his daughter whose life as a personal secretary is not quite what it seems.
That son sits by the side of the stage as a silent observer in a grey suit. He’s on duty from the council to inculcate neighbourly values and check out the plausibility of his own parents as museum pieces. He’s part of an army of time and motion men who finally invade the stage and dismantle Janet Bird’s marvellous, last ditch design of stained glass, flying ducks, patterned wallpaper and cheap furniture.
With a local yob (Peter McGovern) urinating through the letterbox, daughter Linda (Josie Walker) having sex on the floor with the chauffeur (Mark Killeeen) who’s taking her for a Saudi Arabian marital audition in the Queen’s Hotel, and Mam and nosy neighbour Mrs Clegg (Carol Macready) laying out a supposedly dead Dad and discovering his liveliness down below, the show makes Joe Orton look like Listen with Mother.
Luscombe’s production makes a strong case for Enjoy being Bennett’s most radical play, characteristically witty while pushing theatrical boundaries. Steadman quivers brilliantly with mock sensitivity and the songs of Ivor Novello, while Troughton threatens to explode with physical rage until subsiding into tragic insensibility. And Richard Glaves as their lost son closes each act with two of the most moving speeches on the modern stage.
- Michael Coveney
NOTE: The following FOUR-STAR review dates from August 2008 and this production's original dates at the Theatre Royal Bath.
Alan Bennett once said, with typical self-deprecation, that Enjoy, his 1980 comedy of cultural dislocation and filial revenge, could be more accurately titled “Endure.”
He was right in that the play is fairly tough to sit through. Not because it is tedious, but because it taps so painfully on our fears of dealing with aged parents, the disappearance of recognisable communities, the encroachment of the nanny state, incontinence and amnesia.
Wilfred and Connie Craven – Mam and Dad – live in the last back-to-back in Leeds. The area is being decimated, and they are visited by “an observer” in a grey suit with a view to being resettled in a home, or heritage-style recreation of this one. The silent, note-taking Ms Craig is their own son in drag. Their mostly absent daughter – they’re not sure whether she’s in Sweden or Swindon – is an international sex worker.
So the play is ambivalent anyway about the value of what is being lost. Christopher Luscombe’s production for the Peter Hall Company’s summer season in Bath (playing until the end of the month, then touring) pulls no punches, so the excesses of stupidity and ignorance on show can be quietly taken to be signs of quirkiness, even quaintness.
This makes the play even funnier, especially in the beautiful performances of Alison Steadman and David Troughton as Mam and Dad. She is a chattering airhead, with a memory only for the songs of Ivor Novello; he’s a big blob of boredom with no time for anyone who’s educated (ie, his own son, the Bennett character, played with insouciant finesse by Richard Glaves) and an incomplete relationship with daughter Linda (Josie Walker, hilariously brazen).
Enjoy was never one of Bennett’s biggest West End hits (the original starred Joan Plowright and Colin Blakely) but it is a uniquely sour and prophetic comedy and more like Joe Orton than any other of his plays. The laying out of the corpse – springing a surprise erection on everyone, including Carol Macready’s unfazed nosy neighbour -- is one of the most shocking scenes in modern drama, but one of the funniest, too.
Luscombe’s revival, niftily designed by Janet Bird and cunningly lit by Paul Pyant, is a superb reinstatement of a play with much to say and plenty of uncomfortable laughs; Leeds, Bradford and Halifax are on their last legs and, as always in Bennett, affection is subsumed in spikily critical condescension. The West End surely beckons.
I caught up with this under-rated play comparatively recently at the Watford Palace, but was lured back by the casting of Alison Steadman and David Troughton as Mam and Dad. It turned out to be the same director-design team, but I don't regret re-visiting it as the performances are terrific. It's a show which was way ahead of its time when it was first produced in 1980. If I have a reservation, it's that the first half is too slow. The second half, however, is a gem! - Gareth James
02 Apr 09
It's not too difficult to see why Enjoy was a flop first time around. The dialogue between the elderly couple who can barely stand each other is biting, believable and frequently hilarious. But the escalating absurdism of Alan Bennett's story is far too Ortonesque for my taste and at least 20 minutes too long. There are some valid points about the heritage industry but by the end it's difficult to care much. Alison Steadman is wonderful as Connie, apparently on the verge of dementia but unexpectedly sharp on occasion and there is an hysterical cameo from Carol Macready; but Enjoy? - not entirely. - David Baxter
18 Mar 09
We sat in the front row of the stalls last Saturday. Great seats. What a shame we didn't have something better to watch. I have thought it before - that Alan Bennett just doesn't manage to tick all the boxes, does he? The play was amusing, yes, but certainly not laugh out loud stuff. And there wasn't a single surprise, or at least, nothing you couldn't see coming a mile off. Steadman and Troughton were, of course, superb, it's just such a shame they had this poor material to work with. Mind you, a couple of ladies immediately behind us obviously thought differently because any line that managed to raise a faint smile for us had them cackling uncontrollably with laughter. Perhaps they were related to Bennett! The play was worth about £15, maybe £20, but having paid nearly £50 each, we felt we were robbed. Were it not for the fine talent of Steadman and Troughton, we would probably have pressed charges. - Escalus
09 Feb 09
There are some superb performances in Enjoy, which will bring you to the brink of hilarity and despair.Steadman and Troughton command the stage throughout, but are more than ably supported by the other speaking parts who inject their own pathos and uncomfortable humour.The young lad (McGovern)subtly delivers a number of blows,taking the story to a layer of considerable discomfort. This play took me to the limits; laughing one moment, squirming and shocked the next. I would certainly recommend you go. - Tricia
03 Feb 09
i havent seen it yet but im really looking forward to it as my cousin is in the play!!!!! - Carly
09 Jan 09
I saw the same production in Bath before it came to the Westend and its brilliant!! - James
Originally opened 27Dec 1906 as The Hicks Theatre. Formerly The Globe, renamed in 1994 in part in tribute to Sam Wanamaker, so that his dream of a new Shakespeare Globe would be the only Globe in London. 983 seats. Society of London Theatre member. In 1999 Delfont Mackintosh Theatres Limited acquired the freehold of the Queen s and the Gielgud Theatres from Christ s Hospital, Horsham. The lease of the Gielgud Theatre will revert back from Really Useful Theatres to Delfont Mackintosh Theatres in March 2006 after which there are plans to refurbish both venues and to build a 500-seat theatre, The Sondheim, above the Queen s. This will be the first new theatre in Shaftesbury Avenue since 1931.
Whatsonstage.com - Discount London theatre tickets, theatre news and reviews, Theatre videos, Theatre discussion, National Theatre Listings. Covering London's West End, all of Theatreland and all UK theatre. The best
for London Theatre Ticket Discounts.