Synopsis Sebastian died suddenly last summer. His family's inborn pride leads them to reject the bizarre, horrific circumstances of his death. In Tennessee Williams haunting and visceral masterpiece, the truth must not prevail.
NOTE: The following review dates from February 2002 and this production's initial run at the Sheffield Lyceum.
It’s an ominous set. A monolithic steel cylinder stands beneath and just beyond the proscenium arch, while shafts of pristine white light stretch out across the theatre, through torn holes in the structure, as if someone had been at it with an axe.
While you’re mulling quietly over approaches to Tennessee Williams’ symbolism, Michael Grandage’s production of Suddenly Last Summer starts violently, launching parts of the audience from their seats with a sonic explosion. The ruined metal splits open to reveal a triptych depicting a horror-tangled jungle of a garden, carpeted with moss and littered with incongruous red flowers.
Williams was himself undergoing psychoanalysis while writing Suddenly Last Summer and knowledge of this has often influenced design and sound score decisions in a production. But here the battle for a kind of truth through an unhinged sense of righteousness and denial is magnified to the nth degree.
As Catharine, Hamilton delivers a heart-stopping, breathy and tremulous performance, her tiny quivering frame loomed over by Rigg’s Mrs Venable, who becomes increasingly malignant and terrifying, her bluster always accompanied by a crescendo of psychotic bird song. Indeed Rigg seems to dominate the stage, even when she’s not on it. That has to be perfect casting.
As Dr Cukrowicz and Sister Felicity, Mark Bazely and Virginia Denham eschew conventionally pure-white portrayals (he clinically, she angelically so) for more darkly ambiguous interpretations, as they listen to Catharine’s “hideous story” of Sebastian, the poet, the chaste and revered son of Mrs Venable.
Sebastian’s death is the rift between them all, and in their memories of him, they must choose to either ignore unsavoury aspects of his life to preserve his dignity or cling to them for the sake of their sanity. Williams’ themes of all-consuming violence and desire within the constraints of societal mores are timeless - if a little tame these days – and his metaphors remain surreal.
While you’re still figuring them all out, the triptych snaps shut, like a giant flytrap, locking the characters into an asylum of steel, and you with them. Stunning.
This is like a Kinder Surprise egg - genius design, delicious packaging, disappointing at heart. The design is excellent but it does create anticipation that the play can't live up to. The same is true of the soundscape which is a remarkable thing in itself but dominates the production.
The play itself is fascinating, and builds up the arrival of the young woman with the kind of expertise with which a great tragedy builds up its central character before his first appearance. But there is an unforgivable flaw: for its horror and tension, Williams relies on with-holding from his audience key information that ALL the characters know already. Which is cheating - disappointing.
I thought Victoria Hamilton was superb and it's a great chance to see an of-the-moment actress really commanding a big theatre. But Diana Rigg needs to be frailer, more moving and, paradoxically, more menacing. Her house and garden terrify in ways she simply can't (or is that the point...?) It's not a bad performance in a clunky sense - it's completely believable. Just rather lazy. And there were some lines where I realised too late that that there was a (good) joke in there which Rigg (and subsequently I think half the audience) hadn't spotted.
So - over-rated. And at about 85 minutes, overpriced. But it looks good, it's short, and it's better than the average West End play. But then, it's another tranfer. Tip: as with most plays at the moment, go early in the week, book a cheap ticket and you'll probably get a nice upgrade on arrival... - USER: Whatsonstage.com (81.130.107.144)
20 Jul 04
Diana Rigg and Victoria Hamilton are so fine that they leave Mark Bazely far behind, which somewhat skews the dramatic tension. The scenic effect is startling (perhaps too much so?), and the lights and sound are a bit melodramatic. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (12.107.15.2)
14 Jul 04
Aren't we going a little over-the-top here? A very good (but not perfect)production with good (but not outstanding) performances and a good (not astonishing) set of a very mediocre TW play. It does not bear comparison with the NT's recent Streetcar or Electra, but it is very welcome in the West End. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (172.172.121.247)
04 Jun 04
A very good production of an average play. There is no doubt the heightened Gothic melodrama is exciting, but this is essentially two narrative monologues which offer very little probing or insight. The gap left by the production is created by Hamilton and Rigg who, whilst engrossing, never explore the subtext of the material to give it satisfying depth. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (81.152.159.26)
27 May 04
Excellent! Contains two wonderful lead performances and feels like a brand new play. Forget the awful adaptation with Rachael Weisz at the Comedy Theatre a few years ago- this is the real McCoy. Amazing set and eerie music draw you in to to the nightmarish world of Williams. Rigg and Hamilton deserve every award going - they are both fantastic. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (81.131.230.59)
23 May 04
Rigg and Hamilton each dominate their halves of the play, memorably so. Sound and lighting are awesome, in the proper sense of that word. Great. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (193.128.173.20)
21 May 04
Amazing - anyone interested in theatre should go. Victoria Hamilton is excellent, and Diana Rigg is good, but totally outshone by the production as a whole and by Hamilton. Direction and design both exemplary.
By not going, you only cheat yourself. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.194.148.2)
21 May 04
This is a very good production, with fine performances but for me it lacked something and its hard to put my finger on what exactly. All I know is that when I saw it a few years ago at the comedy theatre with Rachel Weisz I was totally emotionally connected to the piece and riveted, it really got inside me. But this production, though technically excellent, left me somewhat cold and detached. But I'd recommend it nevertheless, particularly to anyone who doesn't know the play. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (82.69.37.108)
13 May 04
This is an excellent play that grips you from beginning to end and benefits from being performed without an interval. The entire cast handles the long pieces of dialogue immaculately with Diana Rigg setting the standard in the opening scene. But to experience theatre at its very best wait for Victoria Hamilton’s monologue near the end of the play to feel the hairs stand up not only on your head but all over your body. Do not miss it! You will not see a better drama for a long time!! DJR - USER: Whatsonstage.com (62.255.32.5)
Whatsonstage.com - Discount London theatre tickets, theatre news and reviews, Theatre videos, Theatre discussion, National Theatre Listings. Covering London's West End, all of Theatreland and all UK theatre. The best
for London Theatre Ticket Discounts.