Synopsis Cloud Nine was originally written from a series of workshops exploring sexuality, with Joint Stock in 1978. Often hilarious and extremely poignant, Cloud Nine draws a parallel between colonial and sexual oppression. Set in both Victorian Africa and 1970's London, the play shows how changing sexual behaviours have emerged and, with the onset of a more liberated society, suggests that new as yet undiscovered territories lie ahead. The characters are both joyful and mournful, the dialogue richly comic but painfully acute. The play contains adult themes and language.
Caryl Churchill’s 1979 play Cloud Nine had its origins in a Joint Stock workshop on “sexual politics” and has acquired over the years an almost unassailable reputation as the outstanding theatre piece of its time on that subject.
Thea Sharrock’s revival at the Almeida does little to dent that reputation. What you do feel watching it after so long a time is how formally and structurally unadventurous most contemporary playwriting is – the revival of Ionesco’s Rhinoceros at the Royal Court has had a similar impact. Taking two polarised social situations – British Imperial Africa in the 1870s and a London park in 1979, though the time difference is only 25 years for the characters – Churchill brilliantly created narrative and emotional textures from a mosaic of sketch-like short scenes.
The colonial administrator, Clive (of Africa), is played by James Fleet as a brutish nincompoop whose best friend Harry Bagley (Tobias Menzies) is a sort of gormless sex magnet for Clive’s wife, son, servant and governess. The last is a lesbian with the hots for Clive’s wife (played by a man, Bo Poraj), while Clive’s son (played by a woman, Nicola Walker) is curiously open to suggestion. And it’s all just a tad darker than Hairspray.
Harry is an explorer who thinks of white women where no white women have been thought of before. This skewed archaism in the language is subsumed after the interval in more facile, flexible modes of expression, so that where to live and whom to share with is discussed in more relaxed terms, all guilt removed, even during that still startling speech of Betty (Nicola Walker again; in the first act the character was played by a tiny doll) about the joys of masturbation.
Mark Letheren’s submissive houseboy in the first act becomes a predatory homosexual in the second, while Sophie Stanton’s outstanding double of governess and harassed lesbian illustrates perfectly the two sides of the repression coin. With Tobias Menzies doing a similar job with the furtiveness of sex, Sharrock’s company fully inhabits the playfulness and duality that made Max Stafford-Clark’s original production so delightful and influential.
The only cross-playing in the second act is that of Cathy, a grumpy self-centred child whom James Fleet reveals as the ridiculous Clive reincarnate. The play resounds with such witty echoes and carefully finessed acting. And it all looks very striking, too, on Peter McKintosh’s raised disc of a stage with evocative, silhouetted backgrounds in Peter Mumford’s lighting and judiciously plotted sound effects by Gregory Clarke.
I'd hate to have the job of deciding what plays to revive - particularly ones from the last 50 years. It seems to me very difficult to predict what will still work X years later. There have been many recent successful examples at this theatre - Big White Fog and Awake and Sing this year alone - but I'm afraid, like the recent Rhinocerous and Arsonists at the Royal Court, this hasn't really stood the test of time. It's a play of its time and seeing it today it comes over as clumsy and lacking in subtlety. Probably worth a visit though if you're interested in the recent history and development of theatre - in fact, it's worth a visit to see James Fleet as a litle girl! - Gareth James
04 Dec 07
Rather tellingly there is a photograph in the program which shows Caryl Churchill, Max Stafford Clarke and Anthony Sher cavorting around in the Tower Theatre, Canonbury, during rehersals for Cloud Nine in 1978. The way we did in the seventies - MAN! It's a pretentious piece, not without humour though, and some big laughs even, but rather confused and dare I say twisted in the way playwrights thought they should write back in the seventies. It ain't only the old colonials on stage who show their age. Nevertheless there are some good performances from the uniformal talented cast. Thea Sharrock directs with panache, but why did she bother in the first place when there are so many better plays to revive than this old turkey? Come on Almeida - you can do better than this! - rds
Whatsonstage.com - Discount London theatre tickets, theatre news and reviews, Theatre videos, Theatre discussion, National Theatre Listings. Covering London's West End, all of Theatreland and all UK theatre. The best
for London Theatre Ticket Discounts.