I agree with Gareth, except I feel the problem was with the staging and not the play. We could have seen a much more interesting play if we were focused on the story and not the spectacle which is what I think Lan tried to create. The text is dense, but if care is taken when directing it, it can be very accessible and illuminating to a wide range of audiences. The great performances carried this play, I just feel Lan decisions where slightly uninformed! - Tyson K
18 Jul 10
I've come to the conclusion that the Young Vic doesn't like its audience very much. Still clinging stubbornly to the absurd unreserved seating policy, the stage design for this play includes red dirt spread all around the stalls. Not only did this make a mess of shoes but didn't it occur to anyone that people stash bags and jackets under their seats - anyone doing so would have found their possessions ruined. All of which put me in a bad mood when the play started (late). as has been noted elsewhere it is necessary to concentrate closely on a dense and sometimes impenetrable storyline and some accents which take time to get used to. of course it's staged in the round so much of the dialogue is muffled. This is such a shame because their was some terrific acting on display and others have got much more out of this than i did. - David Baxter
30 Jun 10
Some astounding acting but the play is dense and I recommend you read up before you see it. - addicted to theatre
29 Jun 10
The combination of in-the-round staging and heavy accents means you take a while to atune to this play. Even when you do, it's hard to maintain concentration because it's very slow, partricularly in the first act, in developing characters and story; I often found my mind wandering.
Based on the audience's enthusiastic reaction, I'm prepared to accept that my lack of engagement with it might be more about me than the play or the production. I didn't find it particularly illuminating about the black American experience in 1911. What it says about the recovery from slavery, identity and spirituality seemed to me to have insufficient substance or depth and was frankly confusing. I've got a lot more out of the other August Wilson plays I've seen. What isn't in question though is a fine set of performances, particularly from Danny Sapani, Delroy Lindo, Kobna Holdbrook-Smith and Nathanial Martello-White. I felt the female roles were too underwritten to alow the actresses to shine in the same way as the men did. Notwithstanding the audibility issues, David Lan's staging was very effective, though I'm not really sure why we all had to have our feet firmly implanted in the sand / soil that pervades the seating areas as well as the performance area of Patrick Burnier's design. For me it was another case of good production - disappointing play, but it's fair to say my companion and I were in a distinct minority on the night. - Gareth James
24 Jun 10
A fantastic production, some of the in the round blocking could do with some revision and some of the text is heavy going but a gripping, and moving exploration of American history. - Glen