This 30-year old early Victoria Wood play was given a rare outing on the fringe last year before this higher profile one at the Menier, but it hasn’t really risen to the challenge. The tale of a talent contest in a Manchester club in the 70’s has its moments, but not enough of them I’m afraid. It proves that comedy was a much better vehicle for her observant humour than plays would have been; she chose the right career. That said, I don’t begrudge seeing this 90 minute curiosity again which is well staged and performed. - Gareth James
08 Oct 09
Apart from the first 20 minutes which are set front-of-house at a cheesy 70s Northern club, this really is pretty dire. Sure there are glimpses of the ear for the daft in the everyday that characterises much of the best of Wood's work, but the clumsy direction, leaden humour, sloppy structure and appalling songs mean that this little piece long outstays it's welcome. Old troupers like Mark Curry, Jeffrey Holland and above all the wonderful Mark Hadfield are great value but the two lead girls are decidedly undercast, like watching understudies who've had insufficient rehearsal. Definitely not a must-see! - ajh
22 Sep 09
Back in the days when boys became bands without the unwelcome attentions of Louis Walsh, or girls sang aloud without a televised vote - young Victoria Wood penned a simple, funny and sweet piece for the Sheffield Crucible based on her own experiences backstage in a provincial talent show. +++
Revisiting it thirty years later, she freely admits she had to explain a lot of the references to the cast, so it's not surprising many of the jokes had to be audibly elaborated by the older audience to its younger boyfriends during last Thursday's first performance at the Menier. There is hardly a gay bar in London in which you couldn't hear someone 'doing' a Victoria Wood sketch, and for the previews they were out in force, and lapping up the familiar comic lines. +++
Asked to comment on her friend Julie Walters' appearance in "Mamma Mia", Wood explained to the Daily Mail that musicals 'really weren't her thing' - which may have been tact as Walters was uncharacteristically dire, but also disingenuous since Wood recently wrote 'Acorn Antiques the Musical' with a swathe of pastiched production numbers. For 'Talent', the musical additions are modest parodies of cheesy cabaret songs which mostly serve to give the male cast members an opportunity to perspire in velour suits with polyester ruffles. +++
Wood appears to have cast this production with a number of old friends - Jeffrey Holland, once the comedian Spike in Hi-de-Hi is amusing as a pensioner magician, but former Blue Peter presenter Mark Curry rather less convincing as the randy compere of the rotting Bunters night club. +++
It's like an explosion in the comedy section of the BBC archives, or at least in the skip where they throw the stuff they don't use any more. +++
The stronger casting is in Suzie Toase playing the role created by Wood, and the ever reliable Mark Hadfield doubling a magician's assistant and the night club's catering manageress in the funniest segment of the show when she organises the table allocations. Both these actors excel with deadpanning the flat northern inflections of Wood's dialogue and illustrate both her easy facility with the language, and its ultimate failure to satisfy. +++
To genuine Lancastrians, the camp non-sequiturs of Wood's dialogue "she was going to be a nun but they had tomato soup and she lost her vocation" are heard on any bus from Bury to Bolton every day of the week, and Wood's skill was to spot the patterns and write it down. Custard creams aren't inherently funny, but when suggested by a northern housewife as a more palatable alternative to oral sex, it gets a laugh. +++
Whilst she has undoubtedly become a 'national treasure' through sketches and sitcom, comparison with more structurally capable dramatists like Alan Bennett are inevitably disappointing. In fact, the way Christopher Luscombe's recent production of Bennett's 'Enjoy' outshines 'Talent' despite the fact they were written at similar times, reflect on both Wood's script-updating and directing skills. +++
Sometimes, Talent alone is not enough. +++ more reviews at londonist.com or www.blowstar.blogspot.com - JohnnyFox
21 Sep 09
If you're of a certain age and preferably someone who enjoys 70's Northern humour you'll probably find much to enjoy in this show. If, like me you're that bit younger and not into that humour then its more like a very dated, quite unfunny show. Yes, there are glimpses of the great Victoria Wood at her best but this very much feels like an early piece of her work and very tired. I can't really see why its been revived. Its a shame for the two girls at the centre of the show who are clearly very talented but are not served well by this. - Paul Wallis
