STAY IN-TOUCH
 
Join RSS Feed
Join mailing list






The Year of Magical Thinking
Share
The Year of Magical Thinking
Venue: Lyttelton (National Theatre)
Where: West End
Date Reviewed:

Related Content

Booking Tickets & Show Listings
The Year of Magical Thinking Listing Page
Internal Links
Review Round-up: Redgrave Is Magical at National - 1st May 2008 roundup


Reader Reviews


ScoreCommentDate
starstarstarstarIf an actress has ever transcended her material, Vanessa Redgrave does it here. Throughout the one hour forty minutes of the play, my constant thought was "She deserves much better than this." Redgrave is a uniquely gifted actor whose performance makes one gasp at her memory, her stamina, her enduring beauty, her presence and her faultless delivery (in a perfectly sustained American accent), but I longed for the words she was speaking to actually move me far more than they did. Joan Didion was an unknown name to me, but I can understand why the original book was such a hit in the States: it has that no-holds-barred, let-it-all-out kind of confessional openness which seems to be a characteristic of the American psyche, but which merely causes slight embarrassment here. But, as an acting tour de force from a great lady, it is unbeatable. - sc22 Oct 08
starstarstarstarstarSaw this for the third time and finally worked out how the book was 'magicked' into her hand. Still the best....OK rds, you've got a point. - joesmith01 Sep 08
starstarstarI have to admit that my review is mostly based on seeing it from the third row in New York and being firstly mesmerised by the great Vanessa Redgrave's direct performance and even more direct blue eyes which seemed to stare directly at me, all the more embarrasing because every time I woke up she still seemed to be staring at me. And that's the problem: if you are (a) a woman (b) have been bereaved or deserted and (c) read some Joan Didion you will probably, like 60% of the New York audience, adore this piece to the point of tears. If you have been, like the other 40% dragged along to see the most controversial and statueseque doyenne of the Great British Theatre, a national monument around whom people should be taken in boats like the Statue of Liberty, you may be less impressed ... for whilst this is a theatrical tour-de-force of memory and engagement and for an actress in her fit and vigorous seventies at that ... the material itself is stultifyingly dull. Didion's life was rowed on a raft of total self-indulgence between her swanky apartment where the orchids matched the fabric on the love-seat in a triumph of anal retention that would out-squeeze Martha Stewart, and her beach house in Malibu. Her partner "the writer John Gregory Dunne" was all but unknown - unless you count "collaborating on the screenplay for 'A Star is Born' ", and therefore pretty much uninteresting to the wider world audiences. Didion's work itself is something of an acquired taste, being randomised and self-consciously intellectual - and there are many who would see Year of Magical Thinking more as a piece of therapy than literature. Also throughout YOMT I got the sense that the lunatically-named daughter Quintana Roo Dunne was a mere child at the time of her illness and early demise. She was 39. www.blowstar.blogspot.com - JohnnyFox14 Aug 08
starstarstarI have to admit that my review is mostly based on seeing it from the third row in New York and being firstly mesmerised by the great Vanessa Redgrave's direct performance and even more direct blue eyes which seemed to stare directly at me, all the more embarrasing because every time I woke up she still seemed to be staring at me. And that's the problem: if you are (a) a woman (b) have been bereaved or deserted and (c) read some Joan Didion you will probably, like 60% of the New York audience, adore this piece to the point of tears. If you have been, like the other 40% dragged along to see the most controversial and statueseque doyenne of the Great British Theatre, a national monument around whom people should be taken in boats like the Statue of Liberty, you may be less impressed ... for whilst this is a theatrical tour-de-force of memory and engagement and for an actress in her fit and vigorous seventies at that ... the material itself is stultifyingly dull. Didion's life was rowed on a raft of total self-indulgence between her swanky apartment where the orchids matched the fabric on the love-seat in a triumph of anal retention that would out-squeeze Martha Stewart, and her beach house in Malibu. Her partner "the writer John Gregory Dunne" was all but unknown - unless you count "collaborating on the screenplay for 'A Star is Born' ", and therefore pretty much uninteresting to the wider world audiences. Didion's work itself is something of an acquired taste, being randomised and self-consciously intellectual - and there are many who would see Year of Magical Thinking more as a piece of therapy than literature. Also throughout YOMT I got the sense that the lunatically-named daughter Quintana Roo Dunne was a mere child at the time of her illness and early demise. She was 39. www.blowstar.blogspot.com - JohnnyFox14 Aug 08
starstarstarPerhaps joesmith, but my money is on Penelope Wilton for greatest English speaking actress. However, I saw Ms Redgrave do this in NYC and she was ...extraordinary! - rds05 Aug 08
starstarstarstarstarThe world's greatest English speaking actress shows what she can do. Also a stunning production from David Hare, the incredibly subtle soundscape and lighting and beautiful stage pictures are unforgettable.Six stars at least! - joesmith23 May 08
starstarstarstarstarbum, I've pressed the wrong button again -- meant to give it five stars. - LDE20 May 08
starstarstarWe saw this last Friday, and were also lucky enough to be part of the WOS outing on Monday. It's hard to imagine that this taxing part could be played better by anyone; Vanessa Redgrave's performance was a veritable tour de force. Quite apart from the sheer physical and mental demands of learning what is effectively a one-and-a-half hour monologue, how does one person keep up the intensity without losing the attention of the audience? Well I don't know how she did it, but she did, and I for one am grateful. The opening words,"it will happen to you. The details will be different, but it will happen to you. That's what I'm here to tell you" to me sum up the play. What we are 'treated' to is a narrative of one woman's experience of bereavement. While we can console ourselves with the thought that, we hope, not many of us will have to live through the death of a child, we are all going to suffer bereavement, and we are all going to have to cope with it. Didion offers no platitudes, no 'comfort'. She just tells it like it is, narrating how 'magical thinking' ('what if?') guided her through the first year and enabled her to cope. Her emotional journey from 'cool customer' to grieving widow and mother dealing with the death of her only child is beautifully, and unsentimentally, depicted by Redgrave. The direction is minimalist, and the majority of the 'action' takes place in a wooden chair, the only furniture on the stage. This had the effect of focusing the attention entirely on the words, ditto the backdrops. It was in the quiet, still moments that my attention was most gripped; only a performer of Redgrave's calibre has the skill and confidence to play the silences as forcefully as she does the text. A wonderful evening, full marks to Redgrave and director David Hare. I'm glad I've seen it twice; I suspect a third visit is looming, as soon as the extended dates are announced. - LDE20 May 08
starstarstarstarstarThe National suffers from it's audience being mostly from a certain older age group - and one it's fighting to change - that audience was spoken to directly by this play/subject and had us all in total awe. What we witnessed last night from Vanessa Redgrave is a reminder just how GREAT she is - yes the "play" is okay - but the delivery and inclusion with her audience is total. I've never experienced such sustained applause from a straight play audience - no cheers - just prolonged standing appreciatation of her greatness, and anyone wanting to see just how great should get in there - NOW! - Cliff Grundy08 May 08
starstarstarI agree that the performance is better than the play. Redgrave shows yet again what a great actress she is and what we have lost in not seeing her more often on the stage. But the play (although obviously heartfelt) seems curiously unmoving. - fred08 May 08
starstarstarIt is a privilege to watch such a great performer , yet I could not help thinking that the performance was greater than the play. I am sure Joan Didier's writing read well but unfortunately it made a rather unmoving piece of theatre. Perhaps it was David Hare's rather stilted direction or just that the written word did not adapt well in this instance. See it for the great performance rather than the great content - Richard Sandler06 May 08
starstarstarstarstarRedgrave's performance was astonishing. Amazing, Wonderful, Beautiful. - Theatre Goer '4506 May 08
starstarstarstarstarHad me mesmarised. Redgrave's performance was absolutly astounding. - Maureen03 May 08
starstarstarstarstar An intense, intimate and finally cathartic experience. Redgrave's performance is extraordinary, particularly her involvement of the audience, which is both disarming and discomforting. What an actress! - Southern Lad01 May 08




Write a Review
Give us your opinion on this production, give it a score (1 is low) and a comment
Score:
Comment:
Name:
Required, will appear on website
Email:
Required, will not appear on website
Confirm: Please type in
Please enter this number > SEVENTY-EIGHT < Just the two digits only, without any spaces.


buy tickets buy tickets
buy tickets
buy tickets
buy tickets




JOIN OUR MAILING LIST
Q Why join yet another mailing list?
A Because, if you visit the theatre more than once or twice a year, we could save you hundreds of pounds.



Tickets For Tonight


Special Offers

Theatre and Meal Deals

Click here for all meal deals


© Whatsonstage 1996-2012
SITE MAP COMPANY INFORMATION

Tickets
Buy London Theatre Tickets
Theatre Ticket & Meal Deals
Discount London Theatre Tickets and Promotions
London Theatre Ticket Hotel Breaks

Content
Theatre News
Theatre Reviews
Interviews & Features
Theatre Videos
Opera News & Reviews
Off-West End News & Reviews
Regional Theatre News & Reviewsl
Whatsonstage.com Awards

Meet the Editorial Team
Add a press release to Whatsonstage.com

Community
Discussion board
Community calendar
Theatre jobs
Theatre blogs

Whatsonstage.com Theatre Club
Join the Club
Log in
Current Club benefits
How to get free theatre tickets

Group Outings
What's On Stage Magazine

Mailing Lists
Newsletter - weekly theatre news
Special Offers - discount theatre tickets direct to your inbox

Information Services
What's On - national theatre listings database

London theatre map
A-Z of London Theatres
A-Z of London Theatre Shows

London Theatre Show openings & closings
FAQ
Work for us - current vacancies
Add a press release to Whatsonstage.com
Find and Book cheap UK Hotels

Marketing Services:
Website design
Email marketing & CRM services

Content feeds
Add a press release to Whatsonstage.com

Whatsonstage.com - Discount London theatre tickets, theatre news and reviews, Theatre videos, Theatre discussion, National Theatre Listings. Covering London's West End, all of Theatreland and all UK theatre. The best for London Theatre Ticket Discounts.

Products
Whatsonstage.com
What's On Stage Magazine
Whatsonstage.com Awards
Whatsonstage.com Theatre Club
Testimonials
Contact us
Advertise with us

Terms and Conditions
Privacy Statement

Loading...

Book by Phone:
London Theatre Tickets: 0207 492 1565

Outings & Club: 020 7317 9100

A Bowl of Cherries Tickets  |  A Tale of Two Cities Tickets  |  Abigail's Party Tickets  |  Absent Friends Tickets  |  All New People Tickets  |  Backbeat Tickets  |  Ballet Preljocaj Tickets  |  Ballet Revolucion Tickets  |  Big Pants and Botox Tickets  |  Billy Elliot - The Musical Tickets  |  Blood Brothers Tickets  |  Chicago Tickets  |  Compania Antonio Gades Tickets  |  Coppelia Tickets  |  Cosi fan tutte Tickets  |  Crazy for You Tickets  |  Dancing to Lorca Tickets  |  Danza Contemporanea de Cuba Tickets  |  Don Giovanni Tickets  |  Dr Dee Tickets  |  Dreamboats and Petticoats Tickets  |  DV8 Physical Theatre Tickets  |  Frank Skinner Tickets  |  Ghost the Musical Tickets  |  Hans Klok Tickets  |  Hay Fever Tickets  |  Horrible Histories - Barmy Britain Tickets  |  I Dreamed a Dream Tickets  |  Jackie Mason Tickets  |  Jersey Boys Tickets  |  Jose Merce Tickets  |  Juno and the Paycock Tickets  |  Legally Blonde Tickets  |  Les Miserables Tickets  |  Long Day's Journey into Night Tickets  |  Mamma Mia! Tickets  |  Manuela Carrasco Tickets  |  Master Class Tickets  |  Matilda Tickets  |  Midnight Tango Tickets  |  My First Sleeping Beauty Tickets  |  Naked Boys Singing! Tickets  |  Nederlands Dans Theater 2 (NDT2) Tickets  |  New Adventures Tickets  |  Noises Off Tickets  |  Olga Pericet Tickets  |  Oliver! Tickets  |  One Man, Two Guvnors Tickets  |  Pajama Men Tickets  |  Pet Shop Boys and Javier De Frutos Tickets  |  Pippin Tickets  |  Play Without Words Tickets  |  Rafael Amargo Company Tickets  |  Richard Alston Dance Company Tickets  |  Rock of Ages Tickets  |  Romeo and Juliet Tickets  |  Royal Ballet of Flanders Tickets  |  Rusalka Tickets  |  Scottish Ballet Tickets  |  Sex with a Stranger Tickets  |  She Stoops to Conquer Tickets  |  Shrek - The Musical Tickets  |  Singin' in the Rain Tickets  |  Stomp Tickets  |  Sweeney Todd Tickets  |  That Thing Friday Night Tickets  |  The 39 Steps Tickets  |  The Awkward Squad Tickets  |  The Ballet Boyz Tickets  |  The Comedy of Errors Tickets  |  The Complete World of Sports (abridged) Tickets  |  The Duchess of Malfi Tickets  |  The Importance of Being Earnest Tickets  |  The Ladykillers Tickets  |  The Leisure Society Tickets  |  The Lion King Tickets  |  The Madness of George III Tickets  |  The Marriage of Figaro (Le nozze di Figaro) Tickets  |  The Mousetrap Tickets  |  The Phantom of the Opera Tickets  |  The Phantom of the Opera Tickets  |  The Pitmen Painters Tickets  |  The Royal Ballet Tickets  |  The Tiger Who Came to Tea Tickets  |  The Wizard of Oz Tickets  |  The Woman in Black Tickets  |  Three Days in May Tickets  |  Thriller Live! Tickets  |  Top Hat Tickets  |  Travelling Light Tickets  |  Umoja - The Spirit of Togetherness Tickets  |  Vicente Amigo Tickets  |  Wah! Wah! Girls Tickets  |  War Horse Tickets  |  Wayne McGregor/Random Dance Tickets  |  We Will Rock You Tickets  |  Wicked Tickets