Quantcast

Reader Reviews

The Phantom of the Opera (Her Majesty's Theatre, West End)

Back to Show Details
ScoreCommentDate
starstarstarstarstarI went to Londen on a four-day trip with my school, and on the second day ‘the Phantom’ was on the programme. Being a student at the music academy, I was already familiar with the score of the play, which was composed by Lloyd Webber. I was impressed by this composition, as it is well written, breathtaking at some moments, and very tender most of the time. Knowing a lot about this musical, attending the show was definitely on my list. That evening a dream came true. Sitting on my seat at Her Majesty’s Theatre, I had high expectations for the show and was eager to see how all is done on stage. What an experience!. The spectacle was overwhelming. The costumes, the boat, the candles, the chandelier, the staircase, it was all fantastic. The dancers and the chorus were also superb. After the show, we all shared enthusiastic feelings about the spectacle that we just had witnessed. - Bavo Pevernagie30 May 12
starstarstarstarstarThe best musical EVER! - Morten Aagaard11 May 11
starstarstarstarActually, if i'm honest, this is cheese of the HIGHEST order. But it's AMAZING cheese. All of this is hilarious, but brilliantly watchable. Everything about it is superb, and just bloody great! Just see this, don't bother with the new one! - cassox03 Mar 10
starstarstarstarstarSaw phantom for the second time on tuesday night. I was hoping Ramin was on for his final week, but it was Nigel. I say BUT, however Nigel was excellent, he did a stunning job and created a real balance of character between his hate and cruelty for the outside world and his love for Christine. Gina Beck played Christine and she was superb, she sang as though the part was written for her, great vocal quality but also great interpretation of the lyrics and character, she was a joy to behold. I took a friend to see the show for the first time and he was blown away with the spectacle, grandeur and scale of the show, and I completely agree, this show is still incredibly impressive in comparison to other shows around, in terms of what can be achieved on the stage. Whatever people's views are of Lord Webber, you cannot fault the vision this man had 23 years ago to create such an amazing, visually and vocally stunning piece of theatre. Here's looking forward to Lover Never Dies! - Tim G05 Nov 09
starstarstarI have seen the Phantom of the Opera twice now and both times it has been absolutly AMAZING, i have come out wanting to turn around and walk streight back in agen! Both times i have seen it Nic has been playing the phantom and he has been incredible, he is an absolutly amazing phantom. i dont think that he gets enough credit for how amazing he really is, everyone raves about Ramin which from watching him on youtube i can see that he is fab and i cant wait to see him in Love Never Dies but in my eyes Nic is a brilliant phantom, he gives me goose bumps everytime he sings! The whole cast of the show is fantastic, by far the most amazing musical/show i have ever seen! cant wait to see it again. - Emma20 Oct 09
starstarstarFor Holly - It was Ramin. He does all eight shows and has been solid since he finished some side projects about three months ago. Hasn't really missed a show since end of May, if that. He's better than ever at the moment. - Sam20 Aug 09
starstarstarstarstari saw it last night and loved it. but i want to know who i saw? can anyone help me? it wasnt nic greensheilds because ive met him and i know it wasnt him (he wasnt as tall!) also i think he only played the phantom in may/june ; please help? it might have been ramin but im not sure - holly simmons19 Aug 09
starstarstarfine - wong19 Jul 09
starstarstarstarI went to see Phantom on a special phantom trip by a local Coventry coach firm. We had tickets for the royal circle. Nic Greenshields was the phantom. I had heard a lot about Nic Greenshields and not all of it positive a cousin who went last year was present when Nic forgot his lines (I think that it must have been the same show as the one on you tube.) My cousin had been to see it another five times since then and she says she prefers Ramin but Nic had improved. I loved it. The show was spellbinding and magical. Gina is fantastic and I love her playing Christine. Simon had my daughters heart a flutter in fact it’s a wonder she did not take of fluttering them so much!! Nic is I think one of these phantoms who can still bring an element of surprise and shock. I love his voice. His voice is so strong and it can soothe you and calm you yet it can also turn your blood to ice as well. I love the boat scene and the amazing way Nic sings and with Gina he seems to have control over her. Music of the night was sung so smoothly and seductively that I got a knock in the ribs and people in my row were smiling as I had become so engrossed in music of the night that I also closed my eyes and lifted my head as he sang "let your spirit soar". He certainly had me hooked and reeled in. WOW stranger than you dreamt it. This is the best I have ever hear this sung. It made me tremble and my daughter as Nic used his voice so masterfully if turned your blood to ice and then slowly as he carried on I began to warm towards him and I felt sympathy for him..As a phantom that is. Here was a man born disfigured but a genius having to hide himself away from the world and Christine in her morbid curiosity and bad manner removes his mask that is in some ways his security blanket his safety net. I just loved the show and loved the senses of humour Nic displayed as the phantom. It is his voice I find so beautiful. It would be nice to see Ramin and I don't know why he misses so many shows. I know and can understand that happening in the hot weather. I know people shouldn't but they do I just wish someone could get a DVD on you tube of both Ramin and Nic instead of just the sound. I know they have ushers everywhere but the Americans can lovely footage over there. I also think that Nic greenshields name should be given equal billing. With the Christine's both Robyn and Gina are given equal billing where as nic's name is right at the very bottom. I think it should say Phantom Ramin Karimloo and Nic Greenshields 'alternate' phantom. especially with the heat wave going on I don't know if they are doing this but if Ramin and Nic share out the performances during the heat wave say Nic does a Tuesday matinee and Ramin the night or just alternate as I would imagine all those heavy costumes and make up must be pretty hot and we don't want to exhaust them. I also think it would be nice if the really useful group could on their web site backstage give dates of all known performances where Ramin will be missing as it can work both ways people who like Nic get the chance to know he will perform and those who have yet to see Ramin know what dates to avoid. I know there is always some last moment where an emergency situation arises and that’s understandable but if there are set dates for which phantoms then you can choose. I am doing overtime shifts at the hospital so I can save for some more tickets to go again. Well back to hearing Nic singing music of the night before I get some sleep. it’s been a long and fairly busy night shift tonight. You lovely people out in the sun and it’s my bedtime. - Starchild03 Jul 09
starstarstarstarstarSaw this musical last friday and it was truly amazing! The phantom was wonderful, but I am not entirely sure who played him. The man looked to be almost 3 meters tall! Anyone who knows who I saw. - anna09 Jun 09
starstarstarstarstarI saw the Phantom last Friday nd I have wanted to see it for a long time. In our performance it was Nic Greenshields who was playing the Phantom and he was amazing. We also met him at the stage doorafter that and he signed my ticket and took pictures with us. - Sofie Du Bois02 Jun 09
starstarstarstarstarI love the movie and have dreamed of seeing it on stage. - Elia12 May 09
starstarstarstarstarWhy is everybody complaining about Phantom? I'd like to see you do as well as the current and previous casts! I've seen the previous cast, Ramin, Robyn, Leila and Alex 4 times - they are outstanding. I am sure Gina and Simon are superb as well judging from clips on youtube. Stop complaining and watch it for yourself. :) And the orchestra is simply amazing, sends me chills to my back as soon as the overture plays! - Little Lotte04 May 09
starstarstarOn March 28th 2009 my daughter and I went to see phantom of the opera in London. It was our first time and I had longed to see it but could not afford it as tickets are so expensive and by the time you add transport etc it is equal to a months wages. My aunt treated us with tickets and travel for my birthday. She had checked and double checked it would be Ramin as we had heard Nic greensheilds was not very good and on you tube Ramin certainly sounded the strongest and better of the two. Imagine waiting 21 years and finally you are able to go. What a let down the phantom was. We arrived all hyped up to see the show especially Ramin, only to find out it is was Nic Greensheilds. Not even the staff at the theatre knew why Ramin was not performing and according to his website he should have been. Still i was determined to make my own judgement about Nic and not let it stop my enjoyment. The good seats the lady at the booking office reassured my aunt they were turned out to be row S in the stalls, so right at the very back and we had ordered them four months in advance and they were the only 'good' ones available. my daughter had to have three bolster cushions and i had two in fact most people in our row had two it was the only way we could see the stage. one of the scenes all I ask of you reprise we couldn't even hear Nic yet alone see him as he sounded like a whisper. There were times i wondered if he was actually miming the songs. On music of the night he seemed at one point to pause for longer than 'normal' as if he had forgotten his words. Having said that i did like his Phantom of the opera song interpretation where he kept demanding Gina sing for him, and stranger than you dreamt it was one of the best interpretations I had seen or heard (I watch you tube phantoms) and i loved how in the final lair he called Christine his angel as she went off with Raoul. Gina was brilliant and her voice is fantastic and her interpretation of Christine was very good. My daughter fell in love with Raoul. I did enjoy the show but was not impressed with Nic's performance as a whole and I would not go again if he became the phantom permanently. I also felt cheated as my aunt had to pay £55.00 as it was saturday Matinee normally they are twenty five pounds for where our seats were. I have since noticed on you tube that Nic does a lot of matinee's I feel that people who go to matinee's are seen as not worthy or second best, but you would think on a saturday matinee they would give you the full cast including Ramin as they charge more. Some of the audiance who had seen Phantom before (one person had seen had seen it 27 times) and they all said that Nic was not as good as Ramin and one person had seen Ramin five times and Nic four times and they said Nic was not as good in that peroformance as he had been in others but they much prefer Ramin. This only made me feel more upset. i know it sounds silly but for 21 years i dreamed of going. In that time six of my eight children were dead and my daughter who came with me was just a twinkle in the stars and a glint in the eye when it first came out and now she is 18 years old. I don't know if Ramin was ill or why he never did the show all I know is i felt let down because i had longed to see the show and Ramin. Anyone tell me where the really good seats are other than front row middle of the royal circle?? I am saving to try and see it again, hopefully this time with Ramin as the phantom. - Jackie T01 Apr 09
starstarstarstarstarFinally saw Phantom for the first time this week. Nic Greenshields played Phantom. He was just incredible. I agree that he should be given the full time lead when Ramin Karimloo moves on to the Phantom sequel. He was mesmerising. - Angie S27 Mar 09
starstarstarstarstarSaw Phantom two years ago and seeig it this year again unfortunately not with the best cast i saw..Leila Benn Harris (well done to you) she was amazing and just a spectcle to see..and Earl Carpenter took my breath away when he first came on behind the mirror and i just think that phantom will run for many many more years.. - Matt21 Mar 09
starstarstarstarstarRamin was amazing, best phantom there has ever been. The show itself is soo good i could see it hundered times without getting bored. it's a must see. The cast were incredible but for me no one can beat Ramin Karimloo! - alice sibley03 Sep 08
starstarstarBrilliant. Ramin was the best Phantom, Robyn was beautiful as Christine. An all round fantastic cast. I couldn't believe how young Ramin was when I met him at stage door. For such an young and very good looking man to play a tortured, emotional and at times dangerous man as convincing as he did was amazing. His voice was outstanding. Well done. Also, big kudos for Wendy Ferguson who played Carlotta, amazing. - Thomas20 Aug 08
starstarstarstarstarI think Nic Greenshields was truly the most amazing Phantom and I was so impressed with how pleasant he was outside the theatre after! A true star is here and well can not wait to say I met him when! And he is so sexy! WOW!! - John20 Aug 08
starstarstarstarstarSaw Phantom last night. Finally got to see Ramin as the phantom as last time he was on holiday. We to be honest, Nic was ok and a fine phantom but vocally flat and his acting was a bit weak. Ramin was outstanding. So powerful and emotional. His voice was haunting and seductive. He is an outstanding actor. His screams were gut wrenching when he told them to go. Very dynamic and unpredictable. You can see why theatre goers nominated him for best take over. Him and Robyn North made an amazing pair. Ramin has re-energized the show. He's actually only been there 11 months so I can see why they are hanging on to him. Nic was ok, but needs lots of work. - Shane13 Aug 08
starstarstarstarstarSaw Nic Greenshields play Phantom last week I discovered he's "Stand In Phantom". I couldn't believe it he was incredible, are the producers going to give him the job full time as I'm sure Kariloo is excellent but he's done it for while now. Greenshields is incredible I wonder how much longer they can keep him there? - B Parker08 Aug 08
starstarstarNic Greenshields as the phantom, what can you say, fantastic vocal talent, fantastic acting ability, took my breath away. - Jackie08 Jul 08
starstarstarstarstarHaving seen the show recently I also would like to echo the sentiments of A.Amos.I too cannot believe the criticism of Leila Benn Harris as Christine. I can only think that it must be based on jealousy of such a beautiful talented actress.Leila's performance was the highlight of the show. Her voice has a unique sound, it's phenomenal and her outstanding performance truly took my breath away. Her ability to chest those high notes as well as sing in the most beautiful head voice only goes to show her versatility.I would have loved to have seen her in the concert version of Chess at the Royal Albert Hall recently but unfortunately all the tickets were sold out. I'm sure with her unique voice and talent she'll be a leading lady in the West End for a long time to come. Bravo! - S. Cantanello17 May 08
starstarstarI've seen the Phantom twice & there only one person thats when she comes on stage you can feel her personallity before you see her & thats is KATHERINE GLASSON.Oh why don't people recognise this fact & stop looking at youngester who have not got the stamina to maintain the ability as she have .Not only is Katherine Glasson attactive But oh boy what a voice she put even Leslie Garrett , Katherine Jenkins in the shade when she sings . - Moyra06 May 08
starstarstarstarstarI saw the show for the 2nd time yesterday and have to say it just keeps getting better and better. Ramin Karimloo is outstanding as the Phantom - a truly moving experience. I just can't understand people's criticism of Leila Benn Harris as Christine. Her voice is truly outstanding and her portrayal of the character 2nd to none. Yes, it is in a different style to the original but it works superbly and has really given the show a new lease of life. Her ‘Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again’ will stay with me always! All the cast were superb and I would highly recommend this cast to anyone. - A. Amos16 Apr 08
starstarstarstarstarAbsolutely Astounding! It was my first Phantom, although it has always been a dream of mine to see it. I do have great experience being in personally and watching other West End musicals, and i have to say Phantom blows all the others right out of the water. Nic Greenshields was Phantom and is quite incredible, moved myself and those around me almost to tears, and I am hoping to see him in the role again as he was just perfect. Leila Benn Harris has the looks and the acting, but her voice was off-key at times which, ruining what would have been amazing harmonies. The actual set looks incredible, and Raoul is gorgeous and exactly right for the role. It may seem like a gushing, overdramatic review but to be honest, I feel i can give it no less as the entire show was certainly five-star worthy at least! I hope to return to see it again in the not too distant future, and although Ramin is supposedly very good, I suppose i will have to say it is the performance of Nic Greenshields i will look forward to again. - B08 Apr 08
starstarstarI was suppose to see this show for my eighteenth birthday.....which was in 1992!!! I finally got round to seeing it in 2007. I love the music and have listened to the Soundtrack too many times to mention, so I had high expectations at finally getting to see how it is all done on the stage. Well, where do I start - I'll start with the positives. The spectacle of the show is incredible, the costumes, the boat, the candles, the chandelier, the staircase, it's all fantastic. I also thought all of the chorus and the dancers were extremely good. In terms of the principals, Raoul was very good and the Phantom (Ramin Kariloo) was pretty good. The stand out for me was Wendy Ferguson playing the Diva, Carlotta, she was fantastic! Now to the negative bit - Why oh why did they cast Leila Ben Harris in the role of Christine!!! Yes, she does have a great voice, I'm not denying that, but it's just not Christine, she's a Belter who just happens to be able to sing high aswell. The role of Christine is written in a specific way and there are a lot of girls out there who have the right quality in their voice, but Leila is not one of them. Wishing you Were Somehow Here Again, she tried to belt most of it and then had to swap into her head voice when it got too high and there was such a difference in vocal quality it was excruciating. I'm not blaming Leila, but the people who cast her, but unfortunately her performance really spoilt the whole evening for me. So overall still a great show and hopefully I will go and see it again with a different Christine. - T Garrad31 Mar 08
starPhantom of the opera is spoilt by Leila Ben Haris,This girl over acts like hell.she spend most of the time throwing herself all over the stage and sounds like bonny langford who has just swollowed a vibrator when not note hitting the high notes, which is the only thing she does well.I cannot see how other people said she was good.I have seen phantom 14 times and have always thought it to be the greatest show ever written,but on this girl acting alone it kills the whole show.My children who are big fans of the film thought she was rubbish.this show is still a good show it just needs a good actress in the role of christine - A Etherington28 Jan 08
starstarstarstarstarNormally musicals are not my cup of tea ( or so I thought)but on Saturday night I was totally blown away by the brilliance of the whole production. Especially memorable was Leila Benn Harris as Christine ( i'm in love!). Simply a supreme, breathtaking and beautiful performance. Her stunning voice moved me to tears and her acting was flawless. Ramin Kariloo was totally brilliant too as the phantom. All in all this is a show not to miss. Magnificent! - Peter Smith14 Jan 08
starstarstarstarstarNic Greenshields is on all this week, till Saturday. I totally agree - absolutely stunning performance. I also had tears in my eyes at the end, and his performance of "Music of the Night" had my hair standing up on end. A star performer. Cant believe this show has been running so long, it seems so fresh! But seeing it tonight was like seeing it for the first time - the auditorium erupted with applause and a standing ovation - deserved - at the curtain. I can't reccommend it highly enough, and specially this week. - Frank14 Nov 07
starstarstarstarstarPhantastic! I saw Phantom for the second time this weekend, and I thought it even better than the first time. Having Nic Greenshields as the Phantom, I was astounded to find that he was at the bottom of the cast list as "Standby Phantom". He was breathtaking and his acting moved me to tears. Raoul was played brilliantly, strong in the places he needed to be and tender yet heroic whilst with Christine. We had Leila Benn-Harris as Christine Daae, though while her acting was spot on and moving, I found her voice- which granted was tone perfect even on her E6 in the signature theme tune- to be too throaty and sometimes nasal for the role. I think she is more suited to one of her past roles; "Carmen" in Fame, than in an almost operatic role. 5 stars from me, I shall be seeing this again in the summer, when I take my boyfriend to cut his teeth on his first West-end musical. - Steff12 Nov 07
starstarstarstarstari seen phantom for the 1st time on saturday =)!!!! after watching the flim i had high hopes for the show and im happy to say the show went beyond my expectations. i was amazing i LOVED ramin karmiloo as the phantom his voice made me jump and sent major goose bumps down my spine he was truly brillant his voice/his acting was flawless. also alex rathenbergh was amazing was raoul not only is he excently eye candy he has a voice that words can describe another flawless performance. leila benn harris played christine and she was fantastic althou it a while for me to get used to her, her voice is faultless but her acting seemed abit stiff in the 1st half but she made it up for it in the second part, she really let go and properly shone. seeing her do the scene when christine vist's her father's grave truly had me in tear's she seemed absoutly devastated and really proved how good she really is. so yeah by the end i changed my opinion and thought she was superb also i think she suits christine perfectly looks wise as i said i watched the flim and she was the christine imaged she looks very simalar to the one in the flim!!!! all in all the show is amazing, its dark and gothic but truly truly moving i would definatly recommened it to anyone who's a true theatre buff.. - dani11 Nov 07
starstarstarstarstarGoing to see it for the 23rd time next week. Can't wait. Each time is like the first time, it's a brilliant show and the overture thrills me every time. - iris10 Nov 07
starstarstarstarstarPhantom of the Opera has been running in London for 21 years, and there's no doubt whatsoever as to why. Phantom is a beautiful, gothic love story with a maginifcent score and visual effects. The show is a phonemonon has it's no wonder it has been runing all over the world. Phantom is a show that will have you spellbound from start to finish. - Naomi23 Oct 07
starstarstarstarstarAn absolutely AMAZING show. Since having seen the movie before finally seeing the show on August 4 2007, it was obvious to me that the orchestra sound was not as grand as in the movie...but that's pretty obvious and not by any means a bad thing for the show. Phantom always works and what lacked in sound in some songs like Masquerade (I much prefer the movie version's slightly faster rhythm and grandeur), was made up by strong singing and acting by the company. Especially to be noted was Earl Carpenter, who gave the role of the phantom such depth and strength (not to mention that wonderful voice) and Leila Benn Harris as Christine. Michael Xavier was also a surprisingly headstrong and well-singing Raoul. A pity that such a Phantom as Carpenter had to leave, but instead we'll be getting a fresh and new performance by a promising Ramin Karimloo! Phantom's definitely a show that will live! - Kate26 Sep 07
starstarstarstarstarI saw it on the 14th as well. It wasn't Earl that played the phantom it was Ramin Karimloo. He is an amazing actor and singer and it shows in his portrayal. No wonder he is taking over the role of Phantom in September. The rest of the cast are brilliant too. With Ramin, this show has a new lease of life. So great to see such a young actor to play the role. Can't wait to go again. - Shane19 Jul 07
starstarstarstarstarSaw this show on Saturday, July 14th matinee. A truly breathtaking piece of theatre. I saw the show when the touring production went to Bradford a few years back, but it was even better in London. Leila Benn Harris was outstanding as Christine, but Earl Carpenter was AMAZING as the Phantom and took everyone's breath away with his powerful singing voice. However, I think the star of the show has to be the sets, particularly the stunning chandelier and the incredible opening transformation of the theatre. Go and see it, you won't be disappointed! - Greg18 Jul 07
starstarHas this thing really been running for 21 years? Why? Unlike many Phantom audience members who plan and save and look forward to their visits like a state occasion, I was still mooching around the new Primark in Oxford Street at 7.25 thinking the curtain was at 8, so despite a swift cab to the Haymarket I missed the opening moments. This did give me an opportunity to stand at the back of the Circle for a couple of minutes and survey the two to three full rows of empty seats, giving the lie to the claim on Lloyd Webber's Really Useful Group website that "In London there has never been a seat unsold" ... well there were at least a hundred empty on Monday 14 May 2007, Andrew. Watching the drama unfold, and seeing the stilted performances, you start wondering why it just isn't the hottest musical in the West End any more. I looked up the original cast - Michael Crawford and the queenly Sarah Brightman (who I can't stand anyway) of course, but also the almost as queenly Michael Ball, superb David Firth and pre-Fred Elliott John Savident heading a pretty well-experienced ensemble. Contrast this with the current collection of just-out-of-drama-school hopefuls and regional- theatre-veteran-understudies and you begin to see the flaws. The creaking you can hear isn't just the 21-year-old stage machinery (although that's noticeable enough) it's the cramping of budgets to the point at which the production is as undercast as it is underlit. Some of the performances are so two-dimensional that in their bejewelled costumes and powdered wigs, you're reminded of a pack of playing cards, especially Wendy Ferguson, unsubtle as a heifer in her role as fading diva Carlotta Guidicelli, and Heather Jackson who plays Madame Giry the ballet mistress more stiffly than if she were an exceptionally arthritic Mrs Danvers in Rebecca during unseasonably wet weather in Cornwall. You'd just want to burn the house down with her inside, the wood in her performance could only add to the blaze. Not that the leading men are outstanding: Earl Carpenter has been playing the Phantom for nearly 1,000 performances. If his mannerisms were any more arch, he'd need scaffolding. Michael Xavier is a remarkably unwashed Raoul, more Che in Evita than a suave French Vicomte, and his darting stage moves in odd directions unrelated to the motives of his character made me wonder if he had Attention Deficit Disorder. I certainly did in the second half when most of the tunes are re-hashes of the stuff you heard before the interval, and the plot descends firstly into the bowels of the opera house and then into ... well, bowels really covers it. This was the first night of the “new Christine”, although I couldn’t tell you which one I saw except to say she was shrewish and dark. The role is now being shared equally four performances a week between Leila Benn Harris and Robyn North. This is ostensibly to make audiences feel they are not getting the “alternate Christine” on any given night or matinee. Since both performers are pretty modestly experienced for West End headliners – Ms Benn Harris having understudied the Mistress in Evita, Ms North most recently touring with Shane Richie in Scrooge, you could say it’s Alternate Christine EVERY night. Who thought I’d ever pine for Sarah Brightman. John H www.blowstar.blogspot.com - John H18 May 07
starstarstarstarstarit was the most amazing thing i've ever seen...better then all the other theatre productions i have seen all put together! - emily25 Mar 07
starstarstarstarWhen the film version of Phantom was released I thought I had seen the stage show for the last time. However, the film was not that good, particularly Gerard Butler, and half-price tickets from GILT was a good reason to go back. To answer a question on the Discussion Board, one reason for seeing the same show several times is to enjoy the visual and aural romantic escapism which you can't get from a CD. You can always find something new to appreciate; on this occasion Michael Xavier made a more rugged Raoul, a character who can sometimes be a bit of a wimp. There is a real charge between Earl Carpenter and Celia Graham as the Phantom and Christine and the final scene is played especially movingly. Spamalot's brilliant parody has made the underground lake scene unexpectedly amusing but this is still my favourite Lyoyd Webber show and deserves to remain as a fixture of the West End. David Baxter (27.2.07) - David Baxter28 Feb 07
starstarstarA fantastic show with truly amazing sets, costumes and acting ! It sent shivers down my spine ! Thrilling. - Lindsey Franklin24 Feb 07
starstarstarstarstarPhantom was fabulous last weekend, still a wonderful show after all this time. Celia Graham was wonderful as Christine, she has a beautiful voice and it's amazing how fresh her performance is considering how long she has been doing the show now. Earl Carpenter was very good as the Phantom, although I think I'd like to see someone new in the role soon. All in all, a beautiful show. Jenny xx - Jenny Granger20 Feb 07
starstarstarstarstarA fantastic show, truly magical. Celia Graham was awe inspiring. Absolutely thrilling. - 172.188.131.125)04 Feb 07
starstarstarstarSaw the Phantom the other night and we were sad to find that after all these years it has lost a little of its magic - still a very good show though and among the best in the West End Right now. Earl Carpenter is an adequate Phantom with a beautiful voice that struggles with the higher parts of Lloyd Webber's score, I was pleased by his acting although not ultimately blown away. Christine, played by Katie Knight-Adams was by far the biggest disappointment - who hired this woman for this role? I found her completely inappropriate both vocally and in the acting department - she also looks too old to play the vulnerable ingenue. The supporting cast were generally very good - with a particularly stunning performance from Wendy Ferguson as Carlotta, the usurped opera diva - bravo! I would always recommend Phantom, but as others on here have said, wait for some new cast members! - 84.69.130.128)10 Jan 07
starstarstarstarstarWe went and saw the show last night and we thought that it was out of this world!! The cast were fantastic (especially Christine and Phantom)! This was the second time I watched it and would love to go again. Well done to all the cast!! - 86.143.155.77)28 Dec 06
starstarstarstarstarI went To see the showb for my 18th birthday in Apri this year as a suprise from my mum and stepdad. Both Earl carpenpenter and Rachel Barrel's performances moved me to tears. Earls music of The Night was simply beautiful. I love the show. i think its the best one Mr Webber has done. I don't understand how anybody can not like it. The chandelier at the beginning was electrifying. Well done Earl and Rachel. I hope you both go on to do great things. Rachel you are a star in the making. Absolutely faultless performances from both of you! - 86.141.34.89)15 Dec 06
starstarstarstarSaw Phantom 1 December. After seeing John Owen Jones twice and Scott Davies once I thought Earl Carpenter did a pretty good job, though vocally John was better. I've seen him with Celai Graham and that was superb. The big dissappointment was Katie Knight Adams, I have never seen someone sing and act so badly (and I have seen many shows). I can't believe she is hired for this job. She doesn't look like a young girl but more like a witch, especially when she sings. She completely screwed up the last part ' Think of me' was already was shortened for her awful voice. She lipsynced the duet 'Phantom of the Opera' because suddenly her voice was completely different and with the notes at the end she was too late closing her lips. At that time you heard her voice only over the speakers and not coming from the stage as before (I was very close). I felt sorry for Earl that he had to work with such a bad performer who was overacting all the time. Make sure you see Celia Graham as Christine when you book this show. - 87.210.127.190)05 Dec 06
starstarstarstarstarI went to see Phantom last night,18th Nov, it was the third time I had seen it and I have to say the best. We had the standby phantom Ramin Karimloo and he was fantastic, beautiful voice and totally believable. Christine was played by Celia Graham who was also superb, beautiful voice and wonderful acting,if you get to see these two you will be very lucky. Also loved Wendy Ferguson as Carlotta who made me laugh (not like the famous actress Minnie Driver in the film who was terrible) wish they had used Wendy inthe film, much better. Also loved Rohan Tickell who was very funny as Piangi. Wonderful experience. - 80.3.64.12)19 Nov 06
starstarstarstarstarPure Genius. Absolutely Sensational. Have seen it twice in London, lost count of how many times I've watched the movies and read the book. The songs, the sets the costumes everything is fabulous! Earl Carpenter and Rachel Barrel perfect! Truly wonderful. I <3 POTO ****************************************************************************** - 81.159.63.194)14 Nov 06
starstarstarstarSaw Phantom the other night, Katie Knight-Adams was pretty awful and unconvincing as Christine. Some seroius over-acting completely ruined the subtlty of some of the pieces. Earl Carpenter however, moved me to tears during Music of the Night. Wonderful. I would see in a hundred times over but will wait until a new Christine is cast. - 81.153.30.36)12 Nov 06
starstarstarSaw this show for the fourth time with my wife this week - it's always been our "special occasion" show. Have to say this time we were a little disappointed. While we love the score and the beautiful sets the cast was a little bit of a let down. Earl Carpenter gave a heartfelt performance but struggled with some of the higher notes which was a shame. Overall his performance was good but you can't help feel he's not up to the standards of Dave Willetts, John Owen-Jones and some of the other wonderful actors who have stepped into the cloak before. Raoul was fresh and convincing but Katie Knight Adams as Christine was pretty terrible. Her voice was ok at times but not good enough for this score and rather annoying at times when she sounded like a spoilt brat. Think of Me was a particular low point. Her acting showed no compassion which made the plot seem inconceivable. How could she be torn between these men when she hated one of them? There was also so dreadful overacting on her part in the Music of the Night scene, which we normally love. I'm not going to write Phantom off, we still love the show but I think we'll wait until a new cast arrives, or go and see the other lady who plays Christine. - 62.136.94.22)29 Oct 06
starstarstarstarstarI saw it for the first time on Saturday - AMAZING! I was totally blown away by it and both Earl Carpenter and Rachel Barrel have fantastic voices. A few people said to me that Earl can't sing...he sure as hell CAN! I loved him!!!! This show was fabulous and I wouldn't hesitate in seeing it again...IMO, this cast are better than the original =] - 195.93.21.36)17 Oct 06
starstarstarstarstarWell, from what I have read you either love this show or hate it..... For me, I loved it. I took my girlfriend on saturday Sept 23rd to watch this show, I did not think it would be for me as it is not normally my kind of thing, but the performances of Earl and rachel (Phantom and Christine) were sublime, superb, outstanding. So much so that I am planning another visit to see the show again. This show is a MUST for anyone even of they think it is not 'up their street'. - 82.195.186.223)28 Sep 06
starstarstarSo Dissapointed, waited years to go and see it and really was a let down. the entire show was weak, dated and didn't even jerk a tear in my eye. The show has wasted away and needs a make over, i can't beleive that Les Miserable/Miss Saigon even Beauty and the Beast was better than the Phantom of the opera. What a let down. - USER: whatsonstage (I was so dissapointed, after wanting to watch it for years I finally did but It was like the show has such a high reputation that they didn't need to try anymore. It needed a makeover to say the least, the singing was weak and untouch14 Sep 06
starstarstarstarSaw this production for the 11th time on wenesday. Excellent as always. When that chandellier goes up at the beginning it makes my heart skip a beat. Can't understand how anyone could not love it! Actors were brilliant, phantom wasn't a patch on dave willetts though. =o) Ace night - 80.3.32.6)17 Aug 06
starstarstarstarSaw Phantom for the first time in London the other night and thought it was amazing. The songs were so beautiful and the sets are amazing. No wonder this show has run for so many years. Earl Carpenter was a fantastic Phantom, although, he did stuggle a little bit with the higher notes. The man playing Raoul (sorry I forget his name!) was very convincing and was a worthy opponent for the Phantom! We were a little disappointed to see the alternate Christine, Katie Adams (?) she seemed to struggle with the vocal, particularly the higher notes, and wasn't really up to the role in that sense. Her acting wasn't too bad though, so it wasn't all bad, just a little disappointing. A lady outside the theatre said the principle is much better though, so maybe we should book again! - 84.70.148.254)10 Aug 06
starstarstarstarstarIt was brilliant, It's the most beatiful musical i've ever seen till now. Rachel Barrell David Shannon and Earl carpenter played their parts very well, and i'm sure i going to see the musical again !! - 81.69.238.156)08 Aug 06
starstarstarstarstarChanged my flight home ... $325. Extra night at the Renaissance ... $250. Seat in the Stalls ... $100. See Rachel perform again ... Priceless! Earl and Rachel together are amazing. Moving performance! I even got her autograph. Thanks again, Rachel! Tony - 160.79.134.3)04 Aug 06
starstarstarI was in London and hoped to see Rachel's amazing performance again. I had one of the best seats in the theater. You can imagine how frustrated I was when I realized it was her under-study. Katie was okay but not "moving" like Rachel. Where's Rachel? Anyway, no one knew if Rachel was performing tomorrow so I guess I'll head back to the States and look forward to my next visit to London. Tony - 84.233.192.195)04 Aug 06
starstarstarstarstarWe know Rachels sister and yesterday we went to see it! IT was really good and Rachel is such a good actress! we were so lucky because we went back stage afterwards and it was amazing! we got to see all the tricks and all the stage stuff. It was fantasic! We were so lucky. We got to go to her dressing room and things!!! FloXXX - 86.137.191.254)02 Aug 06
starstarstarstarstarRachel Barrell's sister took me to c Phantom yesterday as we are family frndz. We went out for pizza with Rachel and her sister before hand, thn she went 2 get redi. The show was amazing! Thn we met Rachel in her dressing room n she showed us bkstage and on the stage etc...n showed us how Phantom disappears at the end! I'm nt telin ne1! Bt was amazing, n Rachel's a very good singer!!! 50000 stars. - 86.137.191.254)02 Aug 06
starstarstarstarstarI have seen the performance now twice and i can now say that the Phantom of the opera is the best thing on earth. the storyline is absolutely amazing and by the end of the performance i was sobbing. the acting was amazing and the music sent shivers down my spine. i have also seen the film over 100 times and i am completely obssesed with the Phantom of the Opera and anything to do with it. the greatest thing in my life!! yes i know i am v sad! - 87.74.48.47)28 Jun 06
starstarstarstarstarPhantom is one of the most expressive shows I've ever seen on stage and the show I saw last week (June, 15th, 2006) was absolutely no exception. Earl Carpenter was fabulous, as well as the whole cast and - to mention especially - the crew "behind the curtain" who brings this amazing story to life - with costumes, effects, stage decoration, choreography, makeup, music, ect. - thanks to all of you for this great performance and wonderful evening. And thanks to Andrew Lloyd Webber for this wonderful score! - 83.215.0.147)20 Jun 06
starstarstarstarstarsimply the best show on stage! - 82.44.223.21)06 Jun 06
starI went into the theatre expecting to see a musical, one that has lasted for years on the west end and is SUPPOSED to be good! However, I came out, knowing it for what it really is, a group of people, hardly adequate to be called actors, emotionlessly singing a string of tuneless, equally as emotionless songs. The storyline was dull and I found satisfaction in following the plot, something that before, I took for granted. The characters are thin, with no more than one layer and the actors didn't even try to hide that. If you want to see a musical with any life at all, do not look here, ever. - 82.35.234.141)25 May 06
starIt is rubbish, never watch it ever, Ever, EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!! - 82.35.234.141)25 May 06
starPhantom of the Blah Blah Blah - 194.154.22.52)22 May 06
starWhen I saw this show, I had high expectations, but they were soon destroyed. I have heard a great deal about this show, but if Phantom really is 'wonderful', 'gripping', and has 'an excellent score', then I must have walked into the wrong theatre. I was still waiting to get into it and reach the 'good songs', when the interval came. Whenever I began to get interested in the story, by the very next scene the tension would fall apart. By the time the show ended I was still extremely unsatisfied. The cast seemed tired, and were hardly singing with any emotion at all. The last thing they seemed ready to do was to keep the show running for another year. The only credit I can give to this show is the set, and that may have been the only reason why I actually looked at the stage. I had practically no feelings for any of the characters, and the Phantom was not teh only one who seemed unalive. - 82.35.234.141)21 May 06
starstarstarstarYou cannot fail to enjoy this musical. It has to be one of the top 3 in London. Visually stunning (how do those candelabras come up out of the floor?) Top class singing and acting from all concerned. You can't go wrong with this one. Even if you're not sure about it I guarantee the music will still be spinning around in your head for days to come. ONE THING THOUGH - DRINKS AT THE THEATRE BAR ARE THE MOST EXPENSIVE I'VE EVER SEEN. £10 FOR 2 GIN AND TONICS!!!!!!!! - 80.1.224.8)12 May 06
starstarstarstarstarThis is the best show on earth!! The music is sensational, the cast are supurb and the storyline is timeless. I have never seen a piece of theatre like this before, and it took my breath away. The Phantom was especially good, and the Christine certainly a change from the shrill voice of Sarah Brightman! NEVER GO ON THE BALCONY!! For only a few quid more you can afford a place in the Grand Circle, which is fantastic. Go for the Centre of the Royal Circle, as the Stalls loose the effect of the Chandeleire. I'm just nit-picking, as this is the greatest performence ever!! - 82.38.204.31)01 May 06
starstarstarstarstarSaw the Saturday Matinee and I'm absolutely blown away. Special affects and costumes...fantastic. The singing and acting however was just amazing. Rachel Barrell's performance as Christine was outstanding as was Earl Carpenter as the Phantom. I have to go see this show again... - 82.39.47.35)23 Apr 06
starstarstarstarstarSaw Phantom of the Opera last night (Tuesday 17th February 2006)had Earl playing the Phantom and Katie Knight Adams playing Christine, was absolutely excellent and will definately return, i loved the set and special effects including that chandelier. Earl was even better that Michael Crawford in my opinion, his voice was amazing although J-O-J sings bits of "Phantom of the Opera" better, although he had over 3 years playing the part so what do u expect? - 195.93.21.38)18 Apr 06
starstarstarstarstarBRULLIANT SHOW! ive seen it 5 times!!! - 88.104.36.38)26 Mar 06
starstarstarstarstarHeidi Ann O'Brien = Best Meg ever, you rock!! - 172.203.189.80)26 Feb 06
starstarstarstarstarI saw the show on thursday.It was fabulous.Matt Carmel was playing the Phantom and was really good. Katie Knight-Adams was playing Christine and was absoloutley beautiful.I loved it.Ten out of ten. - 212.183.134.67)25 Feb 06
starstarstarstarstartook my girlfriend to see phantom for her birthday and, believe me, twice is just not enought! the music will stay with us forever.... - 80.3.96.42)16 Feb 06
starstarstarstarstarI saw the show on Saturday, 11th 2006. Absolutely wonderful! Christine ( Rachel Barrell ) is amazing, far better than on the "original cast recording" CD I have ( which made me go to the show ), and Carlotta was also well above my expectations! - 81.185.102.40)16 Feb 06
starstarstarstarStill a fantastic show after all these years, Earl Carpenter is a marvelous phantom. Saw it on Monday so the alternate Katie knight Adams was on, I wasn't impressed with her when I saw her in 2004 and she has only gotten worse since then, in my opinion. - 172.143.187.34)15 Feb 06
starstarstarstarstarWow, what a show.I went to see Phantom for the first time last night and loved every moment.Earl Carpenter was playing the Phantom, he was wonderful.Katie Knight-Adams as Christine was very beautiful and heart breaking.The cast on a whole were very strong.The singing is exeptional, especially from Katie Knight-Adams and David Shannon as Roul.I was moved to tears by the end of the show.A must see. - 212.183.131.161)03 Feb 06
starstarstarI went to see Phantom last night and Katie Knight-Adams had returned as Christine.Her performance was spell binding.I was moved to tears. Katie Knight-Adams voice was seamless, and very beautiful.Earl Carpenter was wonderful as the Phantom.What a treat. - 212.183.128.185)02 Feb 06
starstarstarstarstarFirst time I've seen the show, and it certainly won't be the last. One of the hardest things for any long-runner is to keep the show fresh - especially when the audience are ultra-familiar with the music, book, crashing chandellier etc - this production more than does it. Its so faultless and seemless that you're almost disappointed when it ends that there isn't another half an hour to go. The principles are excellent (especially Earl Carpenter) - but then the whole cast are wonderful. It's nothing short of being an absolutly bloody good show. - 193.37.180.5)06 Dec 05
starstarstarstarstarExpected a great musical experience and got a great experience.Such a fantastic scenery and vocalists.Must see this again. Bravo,bravo,bravissimo... - 194.240.227.224)20 Nov 05
starstarstarstarstarI have just seen Phantom for (only!) the sixth time. It seems to be better every time I see it and on each occasion I find you can also notice something new, by not specically concentrating on the main action. I would agree with others that both Earl Carpenter and Rachael Barrell are excellent. Perhaps needless to say I have already booked to see it a number of times for next year. - 195.93.21.70)06 Nov 05
starstarstarstarstarPhantom just gets better each time you go, miss this theatrical gem at your peril!!! - 81.76.7.149)28 Sep 05
starstarstarstarstarAbsolutely DAZZLING! My 12 year old sister was blown out of her seat by the singing, acting and music alike!! Forget rollercoasters for a thrill buy a ticket, whatever's available and see this show! Especially if Mr Earl Carpenter and Rachel Burrell are still taking the main parts! WOW - 80.47.224.196)20 Sep 05
starstarstarstarstari went ot see it a couple of nights ago, absilutly loved it...i think it si the best show i have ever seen, phantom and christine will bring everyone to tears... well done to everyone for working really hard and giving such a pleasure... definately will go back at some point... - 81.153.119.1)10 Sep 05
starstarstarstarNow a quick word about Phantom, Earl Carpenter was the best Phantom I have seen (i inlcude John Owen Jones in that), rachel Burrell (was it?) had a beautiful voice, Oliver Thornton, ummm not sure, he just seemed to get drowned out, he was more suited to Les Miz imo. theres no doubt it is an excellent show, but I did feel it had started to show its age a bit, especialy with the very noisy sets (espec christines dressing room). Still in my top three, but with Les Miz in my view looking much fresher since its moved, Phantom just seemed to show its age. Its a shame as I have always before given it five stars, but now will have to be four (cant do 3.5) - 213.122.80.39)02 Sep 05
starstarstarstarThis is still a hugely enjoyable night out; it looks and sounds gorgeous, and sweeps you away on a tide of spectacle, romanticism and sentimentality. Earl Carpenter's Phantom more closely resembles Michael Crawford's original than many I've seen, and Rachel Barrell (Christine) is a star in the making: an excellent actress with a superb voice, and enchanting stage presence. The supporting performers are perhaps a little colourless and Oliver Thornton's Raoul is just dreadful. Yes, he looks goos but he can barely act, has a ropey voice and is extremely camp. The sooner David Shannon takes over the better! Still, this will be packing them in for years and years to come. - 195.82.123.181)27 Aug 05
starstarstarstarstarRecently saw Phantom... for the second time, and it was brilliant. One stand out performance especially was the understudy for Raoul, Tom Soloman,who played the part magnificently and he has a magnificent voice to match the character. But passion and enthuasiam was given by the whole cast, who all performed wonderfully. - 82.39.93.177)01 Aug 05
starstarstarstarstar Beutiful, Brilliant and Rachel Barrell had the greatest voice i have ever heard and she was so beutiful - 69.153.28.49)01 Apr 05
starstarstarstarstarI've seen Phantom a number of times over the years and each time it just seems to get better. Recently I took some friends with me, it was their first time, each of them enjoyed it immensely. As the music started, my eyes filled with tears, the shear emotional power it had gripped me once again. By the end of the show all my friends were planning their next visit. All the cast played as if it were first night, each showing their own passion for the show and giving the best performance possible. Well done!! I'm looking forward to revisiting what now feels like an old friend. - 195.93.21.69)25 Mar 05
starstarstarstarstarAfter seeing the film- i was just soo exited to see the stage version and wa i let down? NO I WAS NOT!!! It is an awsome production which left me gob smacked. John Owen Jones is fantasic as the Phantom - i was in floods of tears at the end scene - what an actor!!! - 194.9.188.22)23 Mar 05
starstarstarstarstarI have seen the show twice in the last four months, and am just waiting for my next time. Having not known what to expect from this show, I came away being hooked. The whole cast were amazing John-Owen-Jones, Rachel Barrell etc.. all outstanding, with amazing voices. The music sends shivers down your spine, and everytime you see the chandelier hover above your head!! The music and cast are all sensational. The show is ten million times better than the movie. Seeing it live adds so much more. You cannot appreciate the music, until you have been and sat there. If you only get to see one show on the West End see this one, you will not be disappointed. - 62.252.224.18)14 Mar 05
starstarstarstarstarIve seen phantom 37 times now and i went again last night, just brilliant!!! - 81.174.137.77)20 Feb 05
starstarstarstarstarMy daughter and I have seen Phantom 29 times now, and JOJones still has the power to move us to tears.We are going on his last night, and would like to wish him all the best in his next project. The show has never failed to be wonderful, with the cast always giving their best, and we hope that it can still be as compelling with John Owen-Jones replacement - a very hard task!!! - 81.154.163.0)16 Feb 05
starstarstarstarstarI have seen this show for the second time on february 4th and I was again competely astonished! It's brilliant! I can't find the words... I give special thanks to John Owen-Jones who is an extraordinary phantom! What a voice! What an actor! I wish I could see him again as the Phantom, but I think it will be impossible... He had me cry when seeing him as Jean Valjean e a few years ago, and then again as the Phantom... Thank you and "bravo" Mr Jones! - 212.195.12.170)09 Feb 05
starstarstarstarstarAnyone who dosn't like it is completely stuped! - 212.85.21.178)17 Jan 05
starstarstarstarstarI just visited London a few days ago and saw The Phantom of the Opera for the first time. I was amazed. Rachell Barrel was wonderful as Christine. Her singing looked effortless as she barely opened her mouth to hit the high notes. Oliver Thornton was gorgeous and was great as Raoul. And of course John Owen Jones was an excellent Phantom. I met the actors at stage door after the show and they were all as sweet as they were talented. I loved England and The Phantom of the Opera! - 152.163.100.201)07 Jan 05
starstarstarstarSaw the show on the 1st. This is my third time seeing it. I originally saw it with Michael Crawford and Claire Moore. I also saw the film recently and couldn't help thinking that Michael Crawford's singing was so much better. Seeing the Musical again I forgot all about Michael Crawford. John Owen Jones and Rachel Barrell were excellent in the parts of the Phantom and Christine. - 81.155.71.143)02 Jan 05
starstarVery disappointed. For a start, I was disgusted with the seats I was sitting in. I know paying around 20 pounds is cheap for the seat in the west end, but missing a third of the show was dreadful. Do they realise that not everyone can afford 45 pound stall tickets, and that if people can't see in the balcony then they will never come again? I doubt I'll go and see again, its not worth 45 pounds. The highlight of the show was the performances from John Owen Jones (Phantom) and Oliver Thornton (Raoul). The set was stunning, well what I could see, and I loved the special effects. However. This show survives on the staging. The music is thin, with about 2 or 3 actual good songs which all come within the first 30 minutes. The rest of the music is just over used, over sang and tuneless. Mr. Lloyd Webber seems to think that just pounding out music for the 5th time in the show as dramatically as possible makes it a good musical. WRONG. This show has been going for 18 years, and from what I can see it, it has been because of the "wow" factor that the set presents. The story line is quite gripping, but slowed down by the music. I don't know what genre ALW thought he was writing, but times it was trying to an opera and at times it was going back to his usual cheesy musical theatre. I couldn't see this musical being entertaining if it weren't for the staging. If this show were to tour with limited money it would fail. I bought the cast recording for one pound before I saw the show and I wondered what the hype was about. I went to see the show, to see what is was like. I could see why it was running for 18 years, but as I said, I was very very disappointed. I give it 2 points. 1 for the set and one for the fabulous cast. - 62.252.192.13)01 Jan 05
starstarstarI've seen Phantom 6 or 7 times and frankly its looking a bit 'tired'. I was disappointed by the principal actors apart from John Owen-Jones as the Phantom. Oliver Thornton as Raoul, Richard Hazell as Firmin and Sam Hiller as Andre all had pretty poor voices. Katie Knight-Adams upper register is poor too. Her acting was 'wooden' to say the least. 'Shape it up' ALW or have the courage to 'ship it out'. - 62.49.41.19)23 Nov 04
starstarstarstarstarThe Phantom of the Opera was an excellent show that I really don't think that the movie could be as good. John Owen Jones was great as was rachel Barrel. Katie Knight-Adams misses notes though. Madame Giry, Meg, and Carlotta were excellent. You must see this, once you do, you'll go again, the songs stay in your head all day. I bought the complete cd and I still go see it again. - 216.49.163.25)19 Nov 04
starstarDull Dull Dull. A show I've heard so much about turned out to be a crushing bore. - 62.254.189.98)08 Nov 04
starstarstarstarstarPHWOAR! What a show! From beginning to end, it took my breath away. John Owen-Jones as the phantom was phenomonal and Oliver Thornton as Raoul sang and looked beautiful. All credit to Sally Harrison (Carlotta), Heather Jackson (Mme Giry) and Meg (Claire Tilling) in the female roles: they really held it together and gave a great performance. The tone was brought down slightly by the performace of Katie Knight-Adams who really let the others down with her lamentable top notes and over-breathing. Her phrasing was appalling in places but her acting was acceptable, All credit to the other performers. All in all, a fabulous performace! 10 OUT OF 10!! - 195.93.33.13)06 Nov 04
starstarstarstarstarI dont care what these negative people are saying. I seen the show on its 18th birthday and it was fabulous! Rachel Barrel, Heather Jackson and Sally Harrison were perfect. SPECIAL MENTION TO CLAIRE TILLING as MEG. Best portrayal of Meg ive seen. Angel of Music and Prima Donna were my highlights. The click track used in the title track seemed clearer and crisper, and it just took my breath away. That was my 5th time at Phantom, and every time i go, I appreciate more what a special piece of theatre this is. BRILLIANT BRILLIANT BRILLIANT! - 82.39.83.190)21 Oct 04
starstarstarstarstarIve now lost count how many times ive seen this show, it's just THE best musical ever produced!! It never fails to impress me. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (81.174.137.77)05 Oct 04
starstarstarstarstarBRILLIANT - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.93.34.14)19 Sep 04
starstarstarstarstarHave waited a long time to see this show and was it worth the wait? Most definately. John Owen-Jones has a brilliant voice and Oliver Thornton was born to play Raoul. The sets were outstanding and the costumes magnificant. Overall one of the best shows in the West End and I hope it runs and runs forever. Can't wait to see it again. Well done to a brilliant cast. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (82.39.91.47)15 Sep 04
starstarstarstarstarSaw Phantom for the first time yesterday. It was BRILLIANT. John Oween Jones as the Phantom was fantastic as was Rachel Barrell as Christine, lovely voice.Having recently seen Oliver Thornton in Les Mis, he was just as great as I expected. The supporting cast were great as well and the scenery was fantastic. Overall I relly enjoyed it and would definately see it again several times over!!! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (82.39.91.47)15 Sep 04
starstarstarFrom Mrs San Pietro, Vancouver BC, Canada Like Chicago have seen this show a lot. We saw a Tuesday matinee of this and the females in particular were not very impressive, though we liked the Raoul guy an awful lot. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (212.137.34.25)03 Aug 04
starstarstarstarstarJUST PERFECT - USER: Whatsonstage.com (62.255.64.8)28 Jul 04
starstarstarstarstarIt's very original. I can't wait to see it again in October. I'm taking some friends this time...the same friends who loved 'We Will Rock You', so I'm hoping they'll have the same opinion about Phantom of the Opera!! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (82.3.32.72)25 Jul 04
starstarstarstarstarHaving seen "Phantom of the Opera" in several countries, it is a very special feeling when seeing it in London. Simply because the production was designer for Her Majesty's Theatre, and you really see how well the sets and such fits into it - in other countries (especially those with a huge stage) it sometimes seems a little unpropotioned. But to the point. The current cast (John Owen-Jones, Katie Knight-Adams, Ramin Karimloo and more) is a very special one. Somehow they managed to revitalize this long running production. I saw the last cast with Celia Graham and Robert Finlayson, and although they were fine in the roles, they were slightly stereotypic. Especially Ramin Karimloo is a fresh breath which adds energy and sprirt both to his role and the production overall. Katie Knight-Adams does the same thing, and her "sucide attempt" in the rooftop scene is already a legend. What I DON'T like about her, is her voice... The fact that they had to transpose some of the score for her, as well as using playback in the title song, is disappointing. Her upper register can be everything from lovely to... well, not there. I've heard her miss some notes. But although she doesn't possess the Christine voice, she is a good singer, and a brilliant actress. John Owen-Jones... What can I say? At his best, he's a genius, and his voice is absolutely divine. A pity he's decided to leave the production in March, but I guess there's limits to how long he can continue to renew his performance. The supporting cast is also wonderful, and as usual, London has a fine selection of understudies (I was lucky enough to see Josie Benson as Madame Giry, and she was easily one of th ebest I've ever seen in the role. Robyn North as Christine and Earl Carpenter as the Phantom are also a treat). The orchestra is also a plus in London. Due to the forthcoming POTO movie, they have some new orchestration here and there, and they have improved the 80's sound in a sublime way. The sound is crisper and clearer, and the overture more booming than ever. London also use the whole theatre to transport the sound (unlike the current US tous, where all sound seems to come formt he stage), and it gives you a creppy and delightful feeling that the Phantom IS indeed everywhere. The London production also have some special "London only" features. What I miss the most in other production, is the graveyard trio in "Wandering Child" - the fact that Raoul enters much earlier than in the international productions. WHY, may I ask, is this only added in London? Also, the Phantom catches Christine when she faints, like the gentleman he is. In other productions, she just falls to the floor. Bottom line: the London production is a must see. I have seen better casts, I have heard better orchestras, and I have enjoyed other performances more. but the total package you get in London right now, is unique and worth every penny. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (193.216.93.141)24 Jul 04
starstarstarHaunting at times, as intended. Several great songs (Phantom of the Opera, Think of Me) but some tiresome ones: possibly too many slow numbers. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (62.254.0.34)11 Jul 04
starstarstarstarI have worked on Phantom of the Opera as a backstage crew in over 800 performances in two different countrys. I have worked in the theatre industry for over 15 yeara and still consider this one of the best musicals and theatre events I have been apart of. From the front you have NO idea what is happening behind the scenes, it is a very large set on a very small stage. So Bravo still to the originals who made this show what it is, and were able to make it work at all. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (203.97.2.242)04 Jul 04
starstarI saw Phantom the other night and quite frankly was apalled at the lacklustre state the show is in with it's 1980's backing and poor sound. It is tierd and still full I notice of some of the same old cast members. The main stars on the whole were good but not exceptional but the smaller chorus parts spoilt the show for me as they didnt seem want to be there. I have seen Phantom all over Europe and The English production should be the best as it is the original but it certainly is not. Come on either stick a rocket under it or put something else in that shed. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (62.252.228.198)29 Jun 04
starstarstarstarstarMy 4th POTO, beginning to feel like a true Phan, this was amazing and if the film is a success I am sure the stage version will just go on and on and on with new customers. John Owen Jones for me gave the best second half performance I have seen yet, and Katie Knight-Adams was the 4th Christine I've seen and for me she really conveyed that she might just stay with this man, of course we know she won't, but it was 'lovely'. And a standing ovation on a Wednesday night in the middle of March for something that has been running nearly 18 years can't be bad, a lot of people went home very happy that night I'm sure. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (62.64.167.95)26 Mar 04
starstarstarStill a fabulous production but now a little dated with the cliched sentimentality of Lloyd-Weber's compositions and some arrangements which at times border on the farcical - including hideous 80s (1980s rather than 1880s) style percussion ruining the signature number. Strong performances from a strong cast throughout. Katie Knight Adams excels as Christine and a terrific showing from the understudy for Madame Giry. A classic of our times but unless it gets a major reworking and update, it is probably time to say a graceful farewell. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.92.67.67)25 Jan 04
starstarstarStill a fabulous production but now a little dated with the cliched sentimentality of Lloyd-Weber's compositions and some arrangements which at times border on the farcical - including hideous 80s (1980s rather than 1880s) style percussion ruining the signature number. Strong performances from a strong cast throughout. Katie Knight Adams excels as Christine and a terrific showing from the understudy for Madame Giry. A classic of our times but unless it gets a major reworking and update, it is probably time to say a graceful farewell. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.92.67.67)25 Jan 04
starstarstarstarstarI'm not an opera fan, but this has definatly changed my mind, i really enjoyed the music and the story is amazing! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.92.168.167)18 Jan 04
starstarstarstarstarYes, John is great, Katie is amazing and Ramin is the best Raoul I've seen. Love the connection between Katie and Ramin. The final lair was electric for all three. Great supporting cast. Would love the sound to be louder and clearer, but hey, it was a great night over all. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (80.45.141.51)12 Jan 04
starstarstarstarstarJohn Owen-Jones as Phantom - excellent - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.93.34.14)12 Jan 04
starstarstarstarstarThank God Niklas Andersson is gone. The rest of the cast remains superlative, and nice to see some new faces in the smaller parts. Definitely worth a look! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.92.67.69)31 Dec 03
starstarstarstarstarIncredibly beautifull! Words can't describe how stunning it is. Although I read the actual novel by Gaston Leroux a few years before, it really moved me to tears. Watching it on stage, was just amazing! It is so romantic, so moving, so mesmerizing. I loved it!! Three words of advice: Go see it!!!! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (81.132.216.248)13 Dec 03
starstarstarstarWhat a difference! The new Autumn cast is amazing and deffinitely an improvement from the performance I reviewed earlier. Celia Graham is gone and Katie Knight-Adams leaves you breathless with her outstanding performance. Her voice just makes you melt with it's purity and clarity and she embodies a lot of what Christine should be without going over the top. John Owen-Jones is still strong, while being ever so slightly manic. Heidi Ann O'Brian makes an impressive and very pleasing Meg and Heather Jackson is a commanding Mme Giry. Possibly the best I've seen. Ramin Karimloo also is a good Roaul although his acting is a little transparent sometimes. The orchestra seems re-vitalised and the sound is deffinitely better towards the front of the auditorium in the dress circle or upper circle where I was for this particularly performance. Watching the massive drapes flying down in the opening sequence from this height is amazing. The direction is still a little too stylised for my liking and goes a bit over the top but at the end of the day great performances make me overlook these small problems. Go and see this cast if you were disappointed this Summer. Worth every penny. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (134.219.202.104)16 Oct 03
starstarstarstarstarThis was my first time seeing The Phantom of the Opera! And by the interval i had already made my mind up that this was one that was a MUST-SEE again! The music was well written and certianly gives you a haunting feeling! John Owen-Jones was super as the Phantom, he preformed "The Phantom of the Opera" and "Music of the Night" absolutely amazing,his voice was mind blowing and definatly left a huge impression on me! I have to say that Celia Graham was excerlant as Christine, and Niklas Andersson was also excerlant as Raoul, Vicounte de Chagny, if i personally was Christine's charecter i would fall in love with him! I remember leaving the theatre singing every song that was in my head! And i definaly would like to see it again! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (80.40.36.73)22 Sep 03
starstarstarWell it was OK. Not as mind-blowing as I'd expected. Incredibly beautiful staging though. Watchable. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (62.60.124.52)15 Aug 03
starHaving seen Phantom approximately 4 times now in London's West End one might consider me something of a fan. You might even go as far to suggest that I love this show so much I'll always come out thinking that my £40 was well spent. Dream on. Despite Phantom of the Opera being my first West End experience at the tender age of 11, I certainly have no loyalty and any that I did have was completely blown away by the poor excuse of a performance I was unfortunate enough to attend this Summer. Before I even get started on how completely pathetic this performance was, I first have to caution anyone still thinking of going to see this show to book their seats wisely. Think Her Majesty's Theatre are going to tell you when your seats are restricted view? No believe me, they wont. Of course, perhaps they don't consider being able to see only half the stage and only half the stage a problem. After all I was only paying £37.50 a ticket. Don't be fooled. If you think that you're going to get quality seats just because you're in the Royal Circle, you're very much mistaken. Front row centre is the best way to avoid disappointment.... well actually it probably isn't. Now I must admit, I love this show to bits. I think it's very well written and Andrew Lloyd Webber's score is truly breathtaking and very tender most of the time. Also, Maria Bjordson's design is truly inspired. Although looking a little tired these days (and we can forgive that, because it is supposed to be set in an old Opera House), the set still makes you think "how did they do that" and still competes with other set masterpieces such as Disney's THE LION KING for it's cinematic effect. Unfortunately the best ingredients are not going to insure a top level performance. I should have known from the live entry of the orchestra in the overture (for once I was actuallly GLAD that a lot of the show is pre-recorded!) that is was going to be a disaster beyond my imagination. Of course the musicians played perfectly, rather in the way I played my grade 8 scales when my music teacher bullied me. Every note was more or less perfectly placed in time, but I the overall mood seemed to be nochalent, almost as if the orchestra felt insulted at having to play the show for another night. It was at best, lack lustre from the pit. Not only was the overture stilted and lacking in any emotion, but the texture was weak and flimsy. Hardly impressive. I stopped silently bitching about the orchestra as they slaughtered one of the best scores in theatre history, simply because my attention was immediately turned to what was on stage. I know that there are supposed to be moments of commedy and the idea is that this is supposed to be stylised and vaugely steretypical but really (ANDRE) and (FIRMIN)'s performances as Andre and Firmin were a little too comic for my liking. The ensemble is strong though, unfortunately I was too busy trying to control the urge to walk out. Now let's turn to the really BIG offenders here. Celia Graham (Christine) seems to be under the impression that I'll really think she's a good performer if she shows me what she learnt at the Amateur Dramatics School of Over Acting. No wait that's too harsh; I've seen much better amateurs. She was so over the top in her manic portrayal of Christine that there were sometimes in which I felt ashamed that this is supposedly one of the best things the west end has to offer. I saw Maria Malmberg, 9 years ago and her performance was stellar. Screaming hysterically, flouncing all over the stage and looking like you're on crack half the time is not the way Christine should be played in my opinion. Sure she can hit the notes which is pretty important but when you want to strangle her because her vibrato and general sqwarkiness is all over the place that seems to be eclipsed. What about the man himself? Well John Owen Jones seems to be a very good singer and such numbers as THE MUSIC OF THE NIGHT, were, dare I say it almost flawless. Again the acting was abismal. John Owen Jones's interpretation of the character who is on stage for all of 20 minutes or so certainly leaves a lasting impression..... a bad one. Most of the sung dialogue is masked by a lot of spluttering and snivelling which engenders a lot of the pathetic and tortured being we expect from the Phantom. It was nice to see this side portrayed, as Michael Crawford's interpretation on the Original Cast recording tends to be a little too perfect. Even so, the Phantom from my performance was a little too 'elephant man' to be truly endearing and pitied partly because it was so comic. Where Jones really comes into his own is the darker and sinister side of the Phantom. The scenes where the phantom becomes angry, especially in the lair were particularly good and Jones managed to strike the right balance between speaking and singing. Such a shame his co-star was too busy trying to upstage him with some embarrising over-acting. Are there any delights to the current production you cry? Well, Hayley Driscoll's Meg Giry is well suited to the part despite being somewhat nasal in places. Mme Giry (played by Liz Robertson) is also well placed. Both of them are surrounded by actors and actresses who seem to think that if they stereotype this up enough everyone will love the show. Both Nan Christie (Carlotta) and 'unknown' (Piangi) have the voices of divas, but tend to take their characters to levels of alarming proportions that you never really believe that they are their characters. Despite other people's criticisms of Nikklas Anderrson (currently playing Roaul), I found him to be perfectly acceptable. I wasn't blow away and in a performance riddled with failing it was indeed hard to spot true talent. The ensemble is generally strong and the singing and orchestra are well balanced which is something that often West End sound teams get wrong. Of course, 18 years will take it's toll on any production. The same happened to CATS. However, you only need to see the stunning production of LES MISERABLES at the Palace Theatre to know that a production can still be breath taking provided the cast have enough measured enthusiasm (as opposed to too much) and true talent. By the final scenes, I can't take it. This isn't theatre, it's a disaster area. They are certainly right; it IS London's most haunting love story. I had to rush home and get my beloved Original Cast Recording out and listen to erase the memory of what I've just seen. Lloyd Webber needs to stop worrying about taking BOMBAY DREAMS to Broadway, and attend just ONE performance of this show to see what's happened to it. On the other hand, it's quite clear that he's not that bothered. Mass slaughter is needed here job wise and I suggest we start sooner rather than later. Still want to see the show? Well it would seem from the morons around me who clapped enthusiastically at the end that maybe I'm being over-critical. If you haven't seen the show before and haven't heard the OCR, then you will be impressed and if you're not a seasoned theatre goer you will enjoy it. However, if you appreciate good theatre or are an intelligent fan of the show, then wait for a cast change and get the best seats. I really hope this show hasn't gone past the point of no return, but certainly after the performance I went to (and we're talking a Wednesday night here) there was no doubt in my mind that this shouldn't be on the West End in it's current state. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.92.168.167)07 Aug 03
starstarstarstarstarOkay, Andrew Lloyd Webber's churned out some rubbish but he deserves every accolaide he's ever recieved for giving this great show to the world. Nothing else compares. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.92.67.65)03 Aug 03
starstarstarstarstarI defy you not to be moved by this one! Forget every other musical, this is the Jewel in the Crown of London's West End. Phantom Phorever! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.92.67.65)03 Aug 03
starstarstarstarstarStill the best show in London after all these years, I loved every minute. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.92.67.65)03 Aug 03
starPlease get this boring old tosh off the West End,out dated ,stale and utterly boring.Yuk! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (217.36.117.39)19 Jul 03
starstarstarstarstarthis showis soooo goooood i just dont jknow what else to put but hurry up shuit up and go it is the best ever musical in the world it casnnot be beaten . - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.93.50.14)12 Jul 03
starstarstarstarstarAbsolutely Fantastic. Before I saw this, I was not particularly interested in Phantom, but I was mesmerized throughout. Now I am a huge Phan! Its a must see. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (217.42.53.88)30 Jun 03
starstarstarstarNiklas Andersson's performance as Raoul is very impressive.His voice is stunning and the acting is much more passionate than previous performers. John Owen Jones and Celia Graham are simply fabulous! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (80.40.6.12)03 Jun 03
starstarstarLoses a couple of stars for Niklas Andersson's disappointing performance as Raoul. Still good, and still definitely worth a look - but perhaps worth waiting until October for the cast change. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.92.194.15)17 May 03
starstarstarstarstarThis is theatre at its very best. A true spectacle, a feast of the senses. There are no holes barred here and Phantom never ceases to amaze. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (143.167.77.32)13 May 03
starstarstarstarstarWOW!!! Go and see this, it's fantastic, wprds can't describe!!! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (143.167.77.32)13 May 03
starstarstarstarstarStill the best show ever nearly 20 years on. There's nothing to top this one. Knocks the socks of Les Miz and My Fair Lady. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (143.167.77.32)13 May 03
starstarstarstarstarJohn Owen Jones is great as the Phantom, he really makes you fear and pity him at the same time. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (143.167.77.32)13 May 03
starstarstarstarstarPhantastic! No more needs to be said, it will make you laugh, cry and come out of the theatre knowing you have experienced a truly great piece of theatre history. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (143.167.77.32)13 May 03
starstarstarstarstarSimply amazing - USER: Whatsonstage.com (143.167.77.32)13 May 03
starstarstarstarstarSimply amazing - USER: Whatsonstage.com (143.167.77.32)13 May 03
starstarstarstarstarStill the best show in London after all these years! May Phantom reign for many more years as the Greatest show the world has ever seen. The two leads are fantastic, and the effects are still amazing. Worth the ticket cost at 10 times the price. Go and see it again and again and again...! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (143.167.77.32)13 May 03
starstarstarstarstarOverwhelming...unforgettable night at the theatre. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (80.195.194.39)21 Mar 03
starstarstarstarstarFirst west-end musical i've seen, i absolutely loved it and plan on seeing it again in the near future. i'm baffled by some of the above low ratings, has the show changed over the past few months or are they insane? - USER: Whatsonstage.com (62.253.96.4)08 Feb 03
starstarstarstarstarA truly wonderful show; and this cast is the best I have seen. Matt Cammelle and John Owen Jones are brilliant as ever; and Celia Graham has a beautiful voice. An absolute dream - still a stunner and, in my opinion, better today than in 1986. - USER: Whatsonstage.com (195.92.67.70)17 Dec 02
starTime to GO GO GO Phantom,sorry pinched that from another Webber show!! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (205.188.209.78)07 Nov 02
starThis cast could end this show as they are so bad and the whole show looks really tired and stale,cant see it lasting through the winter. Time for the greedy lord to call it a day! - USER: Whatsonstage.com (205.188.209.78)07 Nov 02
starTime to put this once giant musical to bed,very dated and set dusty and old and the cast no better than a village hall production in a theatre built for midgets with staff that are the rudest I have ever encountered. Avoid like the plague-£40 for this rubbish a daylight robbery. - USER: Whatsonstage.com26 Oct 02
starstarstarstarstarStill a magical evening. I saw it in 1991 and the present cast are stronger. The music is a joy and the set and costumes are out of this world. I thing Joanna Riding would be a drem Christine after seeing her in 'My Fair Lady' the night before. I really enjoyde the classical ballet movement. - USER: Whatsonstage.com25 Oct 02
starstarstarstarstarTHE BEST MUSICAL WHO HAVE SEEN DAYLIGT... - USER: Whatsonstage.com30 Apr 02
starstarstarstarstarI love this show. Most of the songs send goose bumps up my spine, especially "All I ask of You". Poor Phantom, you hate him but you love him. - USER: Whatsonstage.com26 Apr 02
starstarstarstarVery good, the opening scene is one of the best and gripping in the West End at the moment. The Phantom lair scenes are superb, with the exception of the prop marked floor :S There were just three major let downs, 1, The stage floor squeaked. 2, The orchestra and actors were very very quiet.. needed to be louder. 3, It's starting to look fairly shabby in places, but otherwise very good. Do any characters mime? - I am CONVINCED. - USER: Whatsonstage.com16 Mar 02
starstarstarstarstarThe Phantom is everything I expected it to be... and more. Without a doubt one of the best theatre experiences you can get. Go and see it now and if you've already seen it, see it again! - USER: Whatsonstage.com01 Feb 02
starstarstarstarstarthe show was without a doubt brilliant a must for everybody - USER: Whatsonstage.com17 Dec 01
starNow that Notre dame has closed, this can again take its place as the worst show in london. Dated, and badly performed by a cast hired for their voices only. Their attempts at acting are desperate and embarrasing. Dont waste your money on it.....hugely disappointing. - USER: Whatsonstage.com08 Nov 01
starstarstarstarstarBRILLIANT!! - USER: Whatsonstage.com22 Sep 01
starstarstarstarstarwhat can i say JUST GO AND SEE IT...IT'S BRILLIANT.. GO GO GO GO GO! - USER: Whatsonstage.com05 May 01
starstarstarstarstarQuite simply the BEST show in town! Well done ALW. - USER: Whatsonstage.com16 Apr 01
starstarstarstarThis is the only ALW show that deserves to keep running for such an inordinately long run. Great yarn, memorable music, very memorable. - USER: Whatsonstage.com06 Apr 01
Write a Review
Give us your opinion on this entry, give it a score (1 is low) and a comment
Score:
Comment:
Name:
Required, will appear on website
Email:
Required, will not appear on website
Confirm: Please type in
Please enter this number > EIGHTY-NINE < Just the two digits only, without any spaces.


Friends Email: Your Email: Comment: