QUOTE(Steve @ Oct 14 2009, 08:31 AM)

I saw this last night and on the whole was impressed. I've only ever seen the movie before, so wasn't sure what to expect from the play. The set is fantastic and they've obviously spent a fair bit of money on it. Lesley Sharp is amazing as LV's Mum. Her over the top physicality was perfect imo. Likewise Marc Warren was perfectly cast and gave a great performance.
Diana Vicker's was ok, but I had no idea who half the people she was impersonating were supposed to be. Was just someone singing in funny voices. Cilla Black and Shirley Bassey sounded nothing like them. She also didn't really add any depth to the character, like Jane Horrock's does in the movie. She just looked like a sulky teenager who could sing a bit.
The ending was awful too. Why it didn't end with the Mum collapsing outside the house I don't know. That seemed like the perfect ending for the show. But they tack on this stupid rubbish in the club so LV can sing some badly written pop song that has nothing to do with the show at all. Totaly wrong I thought after so much good before.
I thought it was sensational. Agree on the great set and the casting.
Diana Vickers I thought was brilliant. It would obviously help if you knew the people whose songs she was singing but people who did know the songs thought she got them amazingly well.They laughed with Monroe , clapped Dusty and cheered Piaf. Bassey just was Bassey and at full belt. If mine was typical I doubt if anyone in the West End is getting a louder and more positive reception from the audience during and after singing their main performance. It wasn't even as if the audience was packed with X factor watching teens - it was a predominantly middle aged one roaring with approval and giving a standing ovation at the end.
I thought she acted it really well. Totally in role and looked credible throughout - what there is of back story she added and she caught the role of a girl in retreat from the world. Not knowing more about her seems an inevitable and correct consequence of LV not giving anything away to me. It was a brilliant bit of casting to see the similarities between Diana and the character and I doubt if many actresses could act a bigger gap so convincingly.
The purpose of the last song is pretty clear to me too . Ending on a down with Mari in the gutter and leaving it with the future of LV unknown isn't a great ending. Showing Little Voice moving on from impersonation to using her own voice is the obvious place to end if you have someone who is a credible pop singer (Jane would have been acting something else she wasn't which defeats the point somewhat) - it resolves more but leaves unknown where she takes her talent. If you have a pop singer and you don't want her to keep on singing as other people from the past it would be perverse not to let her sing as herself as long as the words fitted the story.
Agree with Mark E - Diana Vickers as LV does a vocal performance that I think is really outstanding, there's a great cast, its full of laughs and there's lots of little gems of LV mimicry all around.