QUOTE(Guest_Jay_* @ May 4 2009, 08:07 AM)

Just saw the show,what a mess!
Rachel McDowell cant do the kicks properly and Aoife Mulholland cant do anything properly!
Ian Kelsey struggles to remember his lines and giggles through most of the show with the unprofessional ensemble who seem amused at his hopelessness!
C'mon Guys- people have paid a lot to see this shambles!
I have seen Ian Kelsey a couple of times and saw absolutely no problem with him. I quite like the sleezier Billys but Ian's less flamboyant one is (more?) credible - an intimate relationship (literally) with the ensemble seems a requirement not a problem.
The ensemble seemed pretty slick to me - the only problems visible were when it had changed recently and thats just probably an argument for not changing it too often.
If anyone thinks Aoife Mulholland can't do anything properly, they should be watching another show as she is doing exactly what she should be doing by the plot and script - from murder to last cartwheel. The UK show hasn't gone with the, older, older Roxie format or attempted to make the show into Prisoner Cell Block H or the film variant . Young Roxie isn't Velma, she's not the more experienced performer or the worldlywise one or the most forceful one nor, given she's ended up with Amos, a massive sex bomb. She's ditzy , fairly but not initially stunningly sexy, and pretty - but she's also bad rather than totally loveable - her murder is down at the psychopathic end of the reasons why all the girls killed. That complexity may not be what you expected to see, but its how the story is written. She is on a learning curve that requires her to match Velma's drive by the end of act 1 and Velma's performance skill by the end - which she does. There's not that many major variations on how you could play a younger Roxie - madder Roxie would disturb, badder Roxie wouldn't deserve sympathy, stronger Roxie, much nicer Roxie or even much funnier Roxie wouldn't match the plot. Suzanne Shaw worked for me as a more likeable Roxie but even there there's the doubt whether her Roxie was just a better psychopath taking more people in. I have seen Aoife do Roxie's journey three times and she's always pulled off the complexity of Roxie brilliantly each time - she's even a good enough actress to slightly change the balance between Roxie the bad, the sad, the ditzy, the good and the comic between shows. I havn't seen anyone do a younger Roxie better.
Havn't seen the show yet with Rachel in it so can't comment - except to note how good Anna-Jane Casey and Tiffany Graves were and the implausibility that they would follow ultra high kicking Tiffany with someone who couldn't kick.
if anything I would make the opposite comment overall - given they have a great Roxie and some great recent Velma's it would be nice if they would actually keep them longer so we would know who we were getting. By all means change the Billys for Jerrys and have guest Amoses (is Justin lee Collins coming back? ) but keep what works in the main roles.