It's showbusiness.... who knows what works.... but at the end of the day they're out there putting on a NEW show
What the hell are you lot doing?
lol thats got to be the most childish comment ive read on here in ages. Reminds me of that guy who posted a youtube video a few years ago telling everyone to leave Britney Spears alone
the only way this could work is either as a pastiche or a serious look at the talent show programmes (ala a chorus line) both of which would mean Cowell admitting how stagemanaged it all is or allow people to laugh at the show. both of which would hurt the brand. if it ends up as an underdog does good and wins type story im not sure the public would buy into that