153 replies to this topic

[morven82]

She is singing well

Hi Everyone!

I agree...it wasn't as cabaret as it could have been, and I think she put her own stamp on it.

I think, and hope, she'll win

[Misplaced]

Poor choice of song  - first on - are they trying to load it  against her.

Gosh I disagree - not at all a good choice for most of the contestants, but I think she could have pulled it off, except I don't think she quite did.  (However, agree it's a tough song to pull off and maybe too tough for tonight.)

[Oxford Simon]

ALW isn't being very fair in his comments

Jodie has a strong voice that would suit the notes as written by Bart

And sly digs about size are just not on now

[Oxford Simon]

That clip of Sam's acting just showed the problem that she faces - she hasn't yet got the acting skills

[morven82]

And sly digs about size are just not on now

Exactly! OK so she talks about it but Nancy is supposed to be Buxom!

[Belle]

Fer Chrissakes, Jodie's not that big!  She's IN the costume, and she looks great.   Sam is tiny, she looks like she'll snap, doesn't seem to give physical strength.

[Misplaced]

And sly digs about size are just not on now

Yeah but I think the sly digs are working against him.  

And good lord, ALW, enough is enough on Sam bringing an audience of hot-blooded men.  The ickiness is positively oozing.  (Thanks, Graham, for cutting him off.)

[morven82]

Really not liking this performance from Sam...

[Oxford Simon]

Without wishing to stereotype audiences - hot-blooded males are not the target audience for Oliver!

Sam as Cilla Black.....

[Oxford Simon]

*yawn*