Posted 20 January 2013 - 11:24 PM
Saw this today. Mixed feelings.
As a spectacle, very impressive. Worthy of all the nominations and awards it is probably going to win by the end of the year.
Anne Hathaway and Eddie Redmayne were outstanding. Pure brilliance every single time the camera was on them: the emotion seeped outwards and I found myself really caught up in it. Would be worthy of any personal accolade. Two of my very favourite moments in the film were I Dreamed A Dream and Empty Chairs and they are the sole reasons why. Zoomed in on their faces, you are right there with them. So powerful.
Hugh Jackman and Russell Crowe are both fantastic actors and they were believable; I bought in to their interpretations and their journies. But they just didn't do it for me vocally. Sure, they can sing in tune and all that, but having seen the stage show and heard such wonderful performances from the likes of Jones, Lewis, Karimloo, Fraser, Rauch and Mutu, their vocals were nothing in comparison. They lacked any power and any 'wow' factor. Bring Him Home is one of my favourite songs and it was just squirmingly awkward listening to Jackman's version. They both struggled (but then perhaps understandably, as neither are singers!). All of the party I saw it with felt the same.
Loved Samantha Barks as Eponine but she seemed to have a much lesser role than on stage. Her voice is so pure and natural and was a joy to listen to. Thought the change of On My Own to before DYHTPS and One Day More was well thought out and worked perfectly.
Amanda Seyfried was alright as Cosette. There's no doubt she can sing but I wasn't overly fond of her characterisation and I found her oddly quite plain and forced.
I liked Aaron Tveit as Enjolras but there was nothing overtly different about his portrayal and sometimes I felt he merely faded into the background along with the other men on the barricades. Marius clearly wore the trousers (pardon the pun) in the pair and in the show they are much more like equals.
Enjoyed Helena Bonham Carter and Sacha Baron Cohen as the Thernardiers immensely. As others have noted on here, their roles are swung more towards light relief in the motion picture and I agreed with this change in character direction. I found them both genuinely amusing and loved the way the Master of the House scene was done in particular, very clever.
Young Cosette and Gavroche were wonderful. Apologies for not knowing their names but they should be so proud. Glad Gavroche got a fair bit of screen time in particular. Special mention too to Colm Wilkinson who is just the epitome of Les Miserables. He just looks right and did the Bishop more than justice. Lovely touch that he was there right at the end too.
It was great fun also playing spot the West End performer thoughout: with Kerry Ellis, Alexia Khadime, Alice Fearn, Gina Beck, Hadley Fraser, Killian Donnelly, Fra Fee and Michael Jibson being among the many I saw.
On the whole very enjoyable and was very well made and thought out. But if you offered me tickets to the stage show or the film, I'll take the live theatre every time.
WEST END SHOWS:
2009: The Sound of Music - Oliver!
2010: Jersey Boys - Les Miserables
2011: Jersey Boys - Shrek the Musical
2012: Ghost the Musical - Jersey Boys - Les Miserables - Shrek the Musical - Wicked
2013: Billy Elliot - Jersey Boys - The Phantom of the Opera - Viva Forever! - Wicked