Quantcast

Michael Coveney
By Michael Coveney

Michael Coveney: Callow revives Ivor Novello at the Proms

Date: 10 August 2012

Thursday night was music night at the Proms, as Simon Callow narrated an Ivor Novello concert played by the Halle orchestra under Mark Elder and sung by the soprano Sophie Bevan and the tenor Toby Spence. It was a joyous occasion, much more than a mere tribute to the unjustly forgotten star of stage, screen and Drury Lane who died in 1951.

If you don't know Novello's musicals - and who does, these days? - you'll know his gloriously inspiring patriotic First World War song "Keep the Home Fires Burning" (while your hearts are yearning), and the irresistibly nostalgic "We'll Gather Lilacs" (in the spring again, and walk together down a country lane); it was thrilling to hear, after so many years, such great melodic light opera numbers as "Some Day My Heart Will Awake" from King's Rhapsody and "My Dearest Dear" from The Dancing Years.

The Dancing Years, aka "The Prancing Queers", is the only Novello show I've ever seen, in a rather tatty touring version by John Hanson (who died in 1988), but the songs have never left me; it was probably the last Novello musical professionally performed in this country... until the Finborough revived Gay's The Word last month. The chorus included Paul Kerryson, now artistic director of The Curve in Leicester, and, as it happens, my younger brother. 

Item after item at the Proms reminded us of just how beautifully Novello constructed his songs, in great melodic arcs, quite demanding of the singer's register, bursting with sentiment and never a hint of cynicism or bitterness. And as Callow reminded us (in a commentary written by Paul Ibell), The Dancing Years (1939) was actually quite a controversial musical, evoking the Nazi threat to pre-war Europe at a time when the British government was bent on a course of appeasement with Hitler.

Callow made an amusing historical parallel, too, with reference to King's Rhapsody (1949), in which a blonde princess, married to the heir apparent, is rejected by him in favour of a much older, and longer-standing, mistress.  

The Halle submitted totally to the lushness of the music, and the singers, Bevan especially, who has a wonderfully rich soprano with contralto elements and beautiful purity at the very top, sang without condescension or fustiness; they really did almost manage to bury the old Radio 2 "Friday Night Is Music Night" stigma of this stuff.

For Novello comes at the end of a tradition of European light opera that harks back to Franz (The Merry Widow) Lehar and Sigmund (The Desert Song) Romberg. His shows were glamorous spectacles, exercises in sheer escapism, crowd-pleasing entertainments.

And he was at least as big a star in the English theatre as Noel Coward, even though he was Welsh. Sandy Wilson, the composer of The Boy Friend, who admired Novello enormously and wrote a superb (and superbly illustrated) book about him in 1975, said that he embodied all the romantic ideals of his age: the Latin Lover, the Sheik of Araby and the Vagabond King.

Dark and dashing, a bit like a mixture of Tyrone Power and Rudolph Valentino, Novello's features also possesed, says Wilson, "in the modelling of the mouth and the flare of the nostrils, a dash of the Byronic aristocrat combined with the more aesthetic breed of royalty - Ludwig of Bavaria, say, or Richard of Bordeaux."

Callow touched on these facets, as well as the minor blip of contravening a petrol rationing law during the Second World War and finding himself in prison for a month (the offence would usually have carried a £50 fine but, said Simon, he was clearly a victim of rampant homophobia, suffering a similar humiliation to John Gielgud's a few years later when caught cottaging).

The amazing thing is that, although he usually starred in all his musicals, Novello never actually sang himself. (John Hanson did, unfortunately, and dyed his hair, too, as Ivor did in later life.) And he was renowned for his social life which featured many old theatrical ladies, two grand pianos and a bevy of beautiful boys. "It's...it's...like...fairyland!" exclaimed a bewildered Margaret Rutherford on attending one of Ivor's parties in the flat he kept at the top of the theatre which now bears his name.

Callow told us how Ivor wrote his box office receipts on the dressing room mirror each night in red lipstick. And how one of his wittier not-so-loyal ladies, Dame Lillian Braithwaite, responded to the chuckle of her companion at a first night as the orchestra struck up the first big tune - "Oh, naughty Ivor, that's an old Welsh hymn" - with the tart remark, "Which is more than one can say of the composer."

The Finborough's Gay's The Word (1950), with lyrics by Alan Melville - Novello rarely wrote lyrics; most of them were written by the poet Christopher Hassall - had a mixed reception, though there is talk of further performances; and I know that Cameron Mackintosh considers the great popular musicals completely impossible to revive nowadays.

But last night's Prom made a very good case for some kind of theatrical extension, perhaps in a longer concert format, perhaps with a brand new book incorporating the best songs in a modern staight-faced context, though it's hard to imagine what that might be.

Whatever happens, last night's treat was more of a revelation than a wallow, although there was only one song - "Pray for Me," an intensely affecting farewell from the composer to his closest friends, Ivor's last song, beautifully rendered by Toby Spence - that I didn't know at all.

Not for the first time in the evening, you realised that there has been only one true successor to Novello in terms of melodic power, unabashed romanticism and theatrical dynamism, and that is Andrew Lloyd Webber. So perhaps we'll have that long overdue Prom devoted to his music next year...   

- by Michael Coveney


Any opinions expressed above do not represent the view of Whatsonstage.com nor any of its staff or contributors beyond the bylined author.



Related Content

Other Posts By Michael Coveney
Michael Coveney: Big Apple bites and Manhattan memories - 22nd May 2013 blog
Michael Coveney: New York honours Matilda with five big awards - 20th May 2013 blog
Michael Coveney: Tales from New York in Kinky Boots - 17th May 2013 blog
Michael Coveney: Finsbury hails its local Park Theatre opening - 15th May 2013 blog
Michael Coveney: Hooray for Halifax and Carrie's ENO debut - 13th May 2013 blog
Michael Coveney: All change at Trafalgar, Liverpool and Finsbury Park - 10th May 2013 blog
Michael Coveney: Critics come full Circle in centenary bash - 8th May 2013 blog
Michael Coveney: High old time with High Tide in Halesworth - 7th May 2013 blog
Michael Coveney: Hytner steams on, Sondheim scintillates - 2nd May 2013 blog
Michael Coveney: Theatre queens and Paris low-life - 30th Apr 2013 blog
 More...
 
Internal Links
Simon Callow revives Mystery of Charles Dickens at Playhouse, 13 Sep - 10th Aug 2012 News


Reader Comments


CommentDate
How nice to hear Ivor Novello given the full orchestral sound it so deserves & from an orchestra as great as the Halle. I felt Toby Spence was not quite up to the mark & left wondering whether he would reach the higher notes. I feel a bit mean criticising him as I have just read that he is getting over an operation for thyroid cancer. My good wishes go out to him on his successful recovery. It was nice to see that the audience appreciated the prom & proved that the music of ivor is just as popular today as it has always been. - Chris Grant

12 Aug 12

I wasn't there but watched the production with another Novello fan on BBC2 on Saturday night. I was bitterly disappointed, as was my companion, not only with the performances of the vocalists, but Callow who does not do the 'tongue in cheek' bit half as well as he thinks he does. His phonetic pronunciation of 'IvOR' ranging to the normal 'IvA' frequently in one sentence and the ham-fisted OTT green carnation touch, presumably from the Director of the Production, rather summed up what seemed to be a hastily cobbled together production made to appeal to a minority audience in what appeared to be a thinly attended Hall. Despite Mr Coveney's rather acerbic and unnecessary remarks about John Hanson, a performer whose reputation was admittedly self-sullied by his tatty touring shows, I find it strange that Coveney feels able to comment on the comparison of the musical theatre of Novello and Drury Lane as he (Coveney) was born only 3 years before Novello's death. Mr Coveney may well have been an enfant terrible, but not, I think, a child prodigy. Once again this production proved to me what I have often thought - the fully trained operatic voice does not lend itself to the delivery of Musical Theatre. The performances of Ms Bevan and Mr Spence came nowhere near emulating the sounds of yesteryear (I think it has something to do with the breathing and a lot to do with interpretation) thus losing the magic and pure romance of the Novello sounds. Ms. Lee whose comments appear here, is not the only one who is fortunate enough to recall the original productions, and clearly time has left a different imprint on our respective memories. Callow's repetitively cheap jibes were to be expected from this performer I suppose and appeared not to receive the rapturous laughter he was expecting from what seemed to be a distinctly thin audience. For that, at least, one can be grateful. The entire production left me with a feeling of an under-rehearsed mish-mash and would have done very little to persuade any viewer unfamiliar with the Novello magic that they had missed very much. - Humphrey Jenkins

12 Aug 12

I was there, and agree totally. What a joy to find an AUTHENTIC rendering of Ivor Novello's music - no 'updated' orchestration, no cuts, no high notes popped in willy nilly, no 'light' soprano and tenor; and how Mark Elder managed to make the Halle sound so amazingly close to the original Drury Lane Orchestra I do not know. The singers were superb, especially the soprano, and the only thing I missed was the absence of a contralto to sing Oliver Gilbert's pieces and the sublime duets with soprano. I really think that if people heard this music as performed last night, there would be the possibility of a revival. Maybe scenes from the musicals? I was so sad when the concert ended, as it was the first time I'd heard Novello's music sound like that since I caught a touring production of 'The Dancing Years' at Golder's Green Hippodrome when I was about 13, with Barry Sinclair, Olive Gilbert, and the original production. I caught the Greenline bus from Welwyn Garden City to see it twice in one week, and have never forgotten it. I've seen a few later revivals, and I'm afraid they were pretty dismal and doubt whether they would have collected many new Novello enthusiasts. Perhaps the Prom team could be persuaded to repeat the evening, using semi-staged items? - Jenny Lee

10 Aug 12


Write a Comment
Give us your opinion on this entry
Comment:
Name:
Required, will appear on website
Email:
Required, will not appear on website
Confirm: Please type in
Please enter this number > SEVENTY-EIGHT < Just the two digits only, without any spaces.

Free Newsletter

Subscribe to our free newsletter


Featured Video

Twitter

Featured Editor's Picks

X Factor musical titled I Can't Sing!, opens Palladium March 2014
The forthcoming X Factor musical will be called I Can't Sing! The Musical and will premiere at the L...

Kazeem Tosin Amore. Photo: Jethro ComptonTanzi Libre
starstar
First things first, it's great to see the Southwark Playhouse open again. Set halfway down New...

Michael Coveney: Big Apple bites and Manhattan memories
You should always do new things in familiar cities. Over the past few days in New York, I walked a...

Kara Tointon in Relatively Speaking. Photo: Nobby ClarkPodcast: Kendal & co in Relatively Speaking Q&A
Last night (21 May 2013), 140 Whatsonstage.com theatregoers attended Relatively Speaking at the West...

Tom Hiddleston. Photo: Dan WoollerDonmar stages Nick Payne premiere, Wesker's Roots & Tom Hiddleston in Coriolanus
The Donmar Warehouse has announced its new season, which features the premiere of Nick Payne's new p...

Jonathan Coy, Felicity Kendal, Kara Tointon & Max Bennett. Photo: Dan Wooller1st Night Photos: Kimberley Walsh & Denise Van Outen toast Tointon in Relatively Speaking
Strictly Come Dancing stars Kimberley Walsh, Denise Van Outen and Artem Chigvintsev toasted former S...

Sealed with a kiss: <em>Spiderman<em>ATG acquires Broadway's largest theatre The Foxwoods, home of Spider-Man
In another significant step for transatlantic theatre relations, the UK’s biggest theatre ...

Video: Sheila Hancock shows wild side in Barking in Essex trailer
As this new trailer reveals, Sheila Hancock has had a dramatic TOWIE-style makeover for her forthcom...

Kara Tointon in Relatively Speaking Review Round-up: Critics convinced by Relatively Speaking?
Lindsay Posner's revival of Alan Ayckbourn's Relatively Speaking opened at the Wyndham's Theatre las...

Felicity Kendal. Photo: Nobby ClarkRelatively Speaking
starstarstarstar
Goodness knows why Alan Ayckbourn's debut success has had to wait 46 years for its first West End ...
>> More Editor's Picks
>> Most Recent Stories
>> Most Popular Stories

Follow Us

Facebook Twitter Google Plus YouTube