Superstar blog: Jesus Christ & other miscastingDate: 17 May 2012With the news that Chris Moyles is to play King Herod in the arena tour of Jesus Christ Superstar, it got me thinking about other bizarre casting choices in other shows. Which cast lists have made you think that it was April Fool's Day when they were announced? Here are some of mine. When Harry Met Sally - starring Gaby Roslin. Picture the scene - we need someone who can carry off the Meg Ryan kookiness - Gaby Roslin? You would have been laughed out of the meeting, but this is exactly what happened. The result? A car crash, particularly during the famous "I'll have what she's having" scene which was unbelievably bad. The Wizard of Oz - starring Russell Grant. Stunt casting gone mad and to all those who say - "Wait until you see him" - I did and the effect was bewildering. He had no stage presence, no timing and could not sing. Ok, some of the songs were designed to almost be spoken but it was the equivalent of watching your uncle get the role. As for the Strictly dance scenes which was added - it would not have got a "sev-uurrrrn." Rent - starring Caprice. Miming, no acting ability whatsoever - one of those nights when you long for an understudy to trip the 'star' up and grab all the limelight. This was one of the worst performances I have ever seen. Idina Menzel played the role of Maureen and in her capable hands there was an off the wall performance with enough emotion within the vocals. Here, there were just tumbleweed moments whenever the lady was on stage. What shows have you seen, which you feel were miscast? Stunt casting - whichever way you look at it, might get people into the theatre and give newspapers something to print but does the bizarre cast choices make the audience stay or go? In the three cases above, you'd beg to get out. Jesus Christ Superstar arrives in Manchester 30 September and Liverpool on 16 October. It stars Tim Minchin, Melanie C and Chris Moyles. Jesus has not been found yet - the search begins soon and we'll be blogging about the show once the auditions are televised. Watch this space.
Related Content
 Reader Comments
|
Buy Tickets
Free Newsletter
Featured Video Featured Editor's Picks
Follow Us
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
 |
|
- Theatre Tickets
- Top Shows (View all)
- 1. Les Miserables
- 2. The Book of Mormon
- 3. The Audience
- 4. Wicked
- 5. Matilda the Musical
- 6. War Horse
- 7. We Will Rock You
- 8. The Lion King
- 9. Peter and Alice
- 10. Jersey Boys
- News & Reviews
-
- News
- • West End Live returns to Trafalgar Square next month
- • X Factor musical titled I Can't Sing!, opens Palladium March 2014
- • Royal Court explores sex, death & Europe this summer
- • Orange Tree stages three-part Middlemarch & Pianist
- • ATG acquires Broadway's largest theatre The Foxwoods, home of Spider-Man
- • Oliver Reed: Wild Thing comes to St James Studio
- • On Golden Pond, Miller & Friel feature in new Salisbury season
- • Donmar stages Nick Payne premiere, Wesker's Roots & Tom Hiddleston in Coriolanus
- • Matilda on Broadway wins five Drama Desk Awards
- View all News »
- Reviews
- Interviews
- • Robert Sean Leonard: 'I carry the ghost of Gregory Peck on my shoulders'
- • Podcast: Ed Seckerson meets actress & singer Lucy Schaufer
- • Pulitzer winner Ayad Akhtar: Islam is 'ripe territory' for drama
- • Brief Encounter with... Park Theatre's Jez Bond
- • Brief Encounter with... 4000 Miles star Sara Kestelman
- • Exclusive Video: Matilda's Bertie Carvel 'interviews' Tim Minchin at Drama Desk Awards
- • Judi Dench: Helen Mirren's drum protest was 'terrific'
- • 20 Questions with ... Travels with my Aunt star Jonathan Hyde
- • Brief Encounter with ... Passion Play's Samantha Bond
- View all Interviews »
- Photos
- • 1st Night Photos: Robert Sean Leonard leaves House for the Open Air
- • 1st Night Photos: Kimberley Walsh & Denise Van Outen toast Tointon in Relatively Speaking
- • Show Pics: Tanzi Libre inaugurates new Southwark Playhouse
- • 1st Night Photos: Celia Imrie & Jill Halfpenny celebrate Limbo opening
- • Photos: Thriller becomes Lyric's longest running show
- • Show Pics: Felicity Kendal & Kara Tointon in Relatively Speaking
- • 1st Night Photos: Maureen Lipman joins cast at These Shining Lives opening
- • Photos: Lloyd Webber unveils £4m restoration of Theatre Royal Drury Lane
- • 1st Night Photos: Billie Piper joins John Simm & Simon Russell Beale at Hothouse
- View all Photos »
- Gossip
- • Clint Eastwood on board to direct Jersey Boys film?
- • West End gets Lucky with Tom Hanks?
- • RSC chef serves up grisly 'Titus Andronicus' pie?
- • This House whips across the Thames for West End transfer?
- • David Hare adapts 'Slumdog Millionaire play' for National?
- • Is Douglas Hodge modelling his Wonka on Wilder?
- • Helen Mirren drums up support for Royal outburst?
- • James Corden on board for Nick Payne's new play at Donmar?
- • Will Tony nominated Kinky Boots stride to West End?
- View all Gossip »
- Broadcast
- Regions
-
- Scotland
- • Hairspray (Tour - Glasgow)
- • Matthew Bourne's Highland Fling (Tour - Glasgow)
- • Thriller Live (Tour - Glasgow)
- • Birds of a Feather (Tour - Glasgow)
- • Doctor Fautus (Glasgow)
- • Goodnight Mister Tom (Tour - Glasgow)
- • Slick
- • The 39 Steps (Tour - Glasgow)
- • The Rocky Horror Show (Tour - Glasgow)
- View the Scotland site »
- • Hairspray (Tour - Glasgow)
- North East
- • The Misanthrope (Tour - York)
- • Live Witness (Newcastle)
- • Albert Herring (Leeds)
- • Albert Herring (Leeds)
- • Noises Off (Tour - Sheffield)
- • Dogs Land (Leeds)
- • Bohemian Rhapsody (Tour - Darlington)
- • The Taming of the Shrew (Sheffield)
- • Opera North announce 2013-2014 season
- View the North East site »
- • The Misanthrope (Tour - York)
- North West
- • WWRY adds Manchester to Arena Tour dates, June
- • Rutherford & Son (Tour - Liverpool)
- • 10th 24:7 Festival - Plays announced
- • Priscilla Queen of the Desert (Tour - Liverpool)
- • Carnaby Street (Tour - Manchester)
- • Starsky's Glaser stars in Fiddler on the Roof tour, Lowry - 29 Oct
- • Brief Encounter with ... Bohemian Rhapsody's Nathan James
- • West Side Story Returns to North West
- • Prodijig presents Footstorm (Tour - Salford)
- View the North West site »
- Central
- • Evita (Tour - Milton Keynes)
- • The Seagull (Tour - Oxford)
- • High Society (Birmingham)
- • Less than Kind (Tour - Oxford)
- • Bicycle Boy (Playhouse Plays Out, Oxford)
- • High Society brings glamour to Birmingham Hippodrome
- • 20 Questions with ... Midnight Tango's Flavia Cacace
- • Sutra (Birmingham)
- • Midnight Tango (Birmingham)
- View the Central site »
- • Evita (Tour - Milton Keynes)
- South East
- • Our Share of Tomorrow (tour - Colchester, Mercury Theatre)
- • Murder in Play (tour - Stevenage, Gordon Craig Theatre)
- • Matthew Bugg on the past, present and future of Miss Nightingale
- • If Room Enough (High Tide - The Rifle Hall, Halesworth)
- • Chewing Gum Dreams (High Tide - The Cut, Halesworth)
- • Smallholding (High Tide - The Cut, Halesworth)
- • The Kindness of Strangers (Norfolk & Norwich Festival - mobile, Norwich)
- • A Pageant (Colchester, Mercury Theatre)
- • Blackout (Norfolk & Norwich Festival - The Garage, Norwich)
- View the South East site »
- • Our Share of Tomorrow (tour - Colchester, Mercury Theatre)
- South West
- • Birds of a Feather (Southampton - tour)
- • Yes, Prime Minister (Bristol - tour)
- • Tosca (Bristol)
- • Bigmouth (Plymouth)
- • Ours Was the Fen Country (Bristol)
- • The Incomers (Bristol)
- • Matthew Bourne's Sleeping Beauty (Bristol - tour)
- • High Society (Southampton)
- • Smallholding (Southampton)
- View the South West site »
- • Birds of a Feather (Southampton - tour)
- Scotland
-
- Specialist
-
- Edinburgh Festival
- • Curtain comes down on 2012 EIF, final ticket sales up 9%
- • Awards flurry as Fringe closes, Edinburgh Comedy Awards, Herald Angles & more
- • Edinburgh Guest Blog: Once a monkey, always a monkey
- • Bereavement The Musical
- • Top ten Fringe one-liners revealed by public vote
- • Reanimator The Musical
- • Virginia Ironside: Growing Old Disgracefully
- • Beats
- • Bottleneck
- View the Edinburgh Festival site »
- Off-West End
- Opera
- Year of the Producer
- • Year of the Producer: Emma Stenning on reopening Bristol Old Vic
- • Michael Coveney: Roar of the Greasepaint, Smell of the Crowd
- • Year of the Producer: Clive Conway's Eureka Moment for An Audience With
- • Year of the Producer: The Donmar Warehouse's Kate Pakenham on … Commercial vs subsidised
- • Year of the Producer: Julius Green on … How to close a West End show
- • Year of the Producer Blog: Kate McGrath on co-running Fuel
- • Educating Rita (Tour - Oxford)
- • Year of the Producer: Barbara Broccoli's Eureka Moment for Chariots of Fire
- • Year of the Producer: Chicago's Barry Weissler On ... Celebrity casting & getting your hands dirty
- View the Year of the Producer site »
- Arts Cuts
- • Time Out acquires Whatsonstage.com, plans future brand growth
- • Kent Leaves Tricycle After 27 Years, Cites Funding
- • Photo: Stewart Leads Equity to Downing Street
- • Drastic Cuts for Yorkshire's Red Ladder
- • Sky Unveils Fund for Projects & Emerging Artists
- • Guest Blog: Philanthropy & Emerging Artists
- • Equity Actors Call for Post-Austerity Arts Summit
- • Cuts: Theatres Trust Say Buildings Hardest Hit
- • Boss Blog: Who's Squealing Like a Stuck Pig?
- View the Arts Cuts site »
- Olivier Awards
- • Oliviers: Lee Evans - 'I really wanted to get back into theatre'
- • Full list & Photos: 2013 Olivier Award winners
- • Oliviers Photos: Helen Mirren, Luke Treadaway & more winners celebrate at 2013 Olivier Awards
- • Oliviers Blog: A view from the red carpet & Piazza
- • Ten of the Best: Quotes from the Oliviers acceptance speeches
- • Oliviers: Michael Frayn - 'I don't think I'm going to write anything else'
- • Oliviers Goss: Thor star Tom Hiddleston back on stage 'by end of the year?'
- • Michael Coveney: Olivier big winners and Stratford long runners
- • Glenn Meads: Oliviers 2013 Blog - View from the armchair
- Edinburgh Festival
-
- Press Releases
- News
-
- Theatre Club
Welcome to the Whatsonstage.com Theatre Club
- Top 5 reasons to join from just £30
- 1. Priority booking for hosted Outings
- 2. Member-only Club Nights, with top-price tickets at reduced prices
- 3. Regular free tickets to shows
- 4. Discounts for several bars and restaurants around London
- 5. FREE ticket to a top West End show when you join - currently Monty Python's SPAMALOT
- View all Club benefits | About the Club | Member-only offers | Current free tickets
- Awards
- Forum
-
© Whatsonstage 1996-2013
